arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2304.09419econ.TH
收藏

关于超级多数规则的线性序尊重问题

Respecting Linear Orders for Supermajority Rules

Yasunori Okumura

AI总结:

本文研究尊重由超级多数规则修正的集体偏好关系的线性序,利用传递闭包与Suzumura一致闭包消除循环,证明所得集合非空且与排名对法和Schulze法相关,并满足扩展孔多塞准则与帕累托原则。

摘要:

我们考虑通过聚合个体偏好而构造的有限备选项的线性序。具体而言,我们关注尊重由超级多数规则导出的修正集体偏好关系的线性序,其中,若出现循环,则通过两种程序引入修正。一种程序利用传递闭包,另一种则采用Suzumura一致闭包,通过一致性调整确保消除循环。我们推导出两组线性序,它们尊重由所有超级多数规则导出的这些修正集体偏好关系,并证明这些集合通常是非空的。我们表明,这些线性序集合与通过排名对方法和Schulze方法所获得的集合密切相关,从而为这些有影响力的方法提供了新的见解。最后,我们证明,属于任一集合的任何线性序都满足两个重要性质:扩展的孔多塞准则和帕累托原则。

英文摘要:

We consider linear orders of finite alternatives constructed by aggregating individual preferences. Specifically, we focus on linear orders that respect modified collective preference relations derived from supermajority rules, where modifications are introduced through two procedures if cycles occur. One procedure utilizes the transitive closure, while the other employs the Suzumura-consistent closure, ensuring the elimination of cycles through consistency adjustments. We derive two sets of linear orders that respect these modified collective preference relations derived from all supermajority rules, and show that these sets are generally nonempty. We show that these sets of linear orders closely relate to those obtained by the ranked pairs method and the Schulze method, thereby providing new insights into these influential methods. Finally, we show that any linear order belonging to either set satisfies two important properties: the extended Condorcet criterion and the Pareto principle.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑