arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2304.07037cs.CRcs.CY
收藏

无捷径可走:去平台化一个极端主义论坛以压制仇恨与骚扰的有效性

No Easy Way Out: the Effectiveness of Deplatforming an Extremist Forum to Suppress Hate and Harassment

Anh V. Vu, Alice Hutchings, Ross Anderson

AI总结:

本文以2022年底多家科技公司联合打击骚扰论坛Kiwi Farms为例,通过定量分析揭示去平台化行动难以奏效:论坛虽短暂受扰但迅速迁移恢复,活动量仅下降约一半,说明缺乏法律强制力时私营部门压制网络仇恨效果有限。

摘要:

世界各地的立法者和政策制定者正在讨论压制网上非法、有害和不良内容的方案。借助多个定量数据来源,我们表明,即使多家科技公司协同付出巨大努力,对一个活跃社区进行去平台化以压制网络仇恨和骚扰也可能十分困难。我们的案例研究是2022年底对规模最大、运行时间最长的骚扰论坛Kiwi Farms的打击行动,这可能是迄今为止行业最大规模的努力。尽管多家科技公司在连续数月内积极参与,这场行动仍未能关闭该论坛并移除其不良内容。该行动虽然短暂提高了公众关注度,却导致了快速的平台迁移和流量碎片化。部分活动转移到了Telegram,同时流量从主域名转向了此前被弃用的备用域名。该论坛经历了数周间歇性中断,之后领导这场行动的社区失去了兴趣,流量被重新导向主域名,用户迅速回归,论坛重新上线并且连接更加紧密。论坛成员自身也在不久后停止讨论这一事件,最终净效果是论坛活动量、活跃用户数、主题帖数、帖子数和流量均被削减了约一半。在没有法院命令的情况下去平台化一个社区,引发了关于审查与言论自由的哲学问题;关于行业在网络内容审核中角色的伦理与法律问题;以及关于私营部门行动与政府行动有效性的实践问题。如果审查者无法使关键维护者丧失行动能力——无论是通过逮捕、禁令还是其他威慑手段——那么利用一系列针对个别服务提供商的法院命令来去平台化一个分散的社区,似乎不太可能非常有效。

英文摘要:

Legislators and policymakers worldwide are debating options for suppressing illegal, harmful and undesirable material online. Drawing on several quantitative data sources, we show that deplatforming an active community to suppress online hate and harassment, even with a substantial concerted effort involving several tech firms, can be hard. Our case study is the disruption of the largest and longest-running harassment forum Kiwi Farms in late 2022, which is probably the most extensive industry effort to date. Despite the active participation of a number of tech companies over several consecutive months, this campaign failed to shut down the forum and remove its objectionable content. While briefly raising public awareness, it led to rapid platform displacement and traffic fragmentation. Part of the activity decamped to Telegram, while traffic shifted from the primary domain to previously abandoned alternatives. The forum experienced intermittent outages for several weeks, after which the community leading the campaign lost interest, traffic was directed back to the main domain, users quickly returned, and the forum was back online and became even more connected. The forum members themselves stopped discussing the incident shortly thereafter, and the net effect was that forum activity, active users, threads, posts and traffic were all cut by about half. Deplatforming a community without a court order raises philosophical issues about censorship versus free speech; ethical and legal issues about the role of industry in online content moderation; and practical issues on the efficacy of private-sector versus government action. Deplatforming a dispersed community using a series of court orders against individual service providers appears unlikely to be very effective if the censor cannot incapacitate the key maintainers, whether by arresting them, enjoining them or otherwise deterring them.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑