修复Kawarabayashi-Thomas-Wollan平坦墙
Fixing the Kawarabayashi-Thomas-Wollan Flat Wall
AI总结:
本文指出了Kawarabayashi等人关于平坦墙定理证明中的错误,提出了较弱的平坦墙定义并修正了定理证明与平坦性传递性证明。
摘要:
Kawarabayashi、Thomas和Wollan近期发表的两篇论文,《A New Proof of the Flat Wall Theorem》(arXiv:1207.6927)与《Quickly Excluding a Non-Planar Graph》(arXiv:2010.12397),对Robertson和Seymour关于排除给定图的有限图结构定理的原始证明提供了重大改进。第一篇论文重新定义了平坦墙(flat wall)的概念。遗憾的是,这一新概念过于强。因此,该论文中新的Flat Wall Theorem是不正确的。附录A中给出了一个反例。第一篇论文中关于平坦性(flatness)传递性的后续引理也是不正确的,Dimitrios Thilikos等人在arXiv:2102.06463中注意到了这一事实。然而,该错误是派生的,并非主要问题。本文提供了平坦墙概念的一个较弱定义,对新的Flat Wall Theorem的证明进行了修正,并给出了平坦性传递性的新证明。本文提出的紧密渲染(tight rendition)概念与Thilikos的定义不同,但定义更为简单,同时引入了正常环(proper cycle)的概念。Thilikos使用的证书(certificates)和倾斜墙(tilted walls)概念被证明是不必要的,传递性以其原有的简单性和一般性得以保留。最重要的是,新的较弱的平坦性定义似乎正是完成Kawarabayashi、Thomas和Wollan第二篇论文中结构定理证明所真正必需的全部条件。
英文摘要:
Two recent papers by Kawarabayashi, Thomas and Wollan, "A New Proof of the Flat Wall Theorem" (arXiv:1207.6927) and "Quickly Excluding a Non-Planar Graph" (arXiv:2010.12397) provide major improvements over Robertson and Seymour's original proof of the structure theorem for finite graphs that exclude a given graph. The first paper redefines the notion of a flat wall. Unfortunately, this new notion is too strong. As a result, the new Flat Wall Theorem in that paper is incorrect. A counterexample is given in Appendix A. A follow-on lemma in the first paper, about the transitivity of flatness, is also incorrect, a fact that was noticed by Dimitrios Thilikos et al in arXiv:2102.06463. However, that error is derivative and not the main issue. This paper provides a weaker definition of the notion of a flat wall, provides a correction to the proof of the new Flat Wall Theorem and a new proof of flatness transitivity. The notion of a tight rendition as presented here differs from Thilikos' definition but is defined much more simply, and the notion of a proper cycle is introduced. The notions of certificates and tilted walls used by Thilikos turn out of be unnecessary and transitivity is preserved in its original simplicity and generality. Most importantly, it looks like the new weaker definition of flatness is all that is really necessary to carry through the proof of the structure theorem in the second paper of Kawarabayashi, Thomas and Wollan.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。