arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2304.00347cs.RO
收藏

将机器人导航建立在自卫法基础上

Grounding Robot Navigation in Self-Defense Law

Carnegie Mellon University(卡内基梅隆大学)

James Zhu, Anoushka Shrivastava, Aaron M. Johnson

AI总结:

本文综合法律、工程与社会科学研究,基于美国自卫法分析地面机器人对人类安全的威胁,提出四项可操作建议以降低自卫情况发生,并指出当前导航方法的不足。

摘要:

在靠近人类的环境中运行的机器人在很大程度上依赖人类的信任来成功完成任务。但当这种信任被破坏时,真正的结果是什么?自卫法提供了一个分析具体失败场景的框架,可以为机器人及其算法的设计提供参考。研究自卫对于地面机器人尤为重要,因为它们在公共环境中运行,可能对附近人类的安全构成合法威胁。此外,即使地面机器人能够保证人类安全,对物理威胁的感知也足以证明人类对机器人进行自卫是正当的。在本文中,我们综合了法律、工程学和社会科学领域的研究,提出了四项可操作的建议,指导机器人学界如何设计机器人以降低自卫情况发生的可能性。我们阐述了当前美国自卫法如何证明人类保护自己免受机器人伤害的正当性,讨论了当前关于人类对机器人态度的文献,并分析了已提出的允许机器人在人类附近运行的方法。最后,我们提出了一些假设场景,强调当前机器人导航方法如何未能充分考虑自卫问题,以及需要这些建议来指导该领域的改进。

英文摘要:

Robots operating in close proximity to humans rely heavily on human trust to successfully complete their tasks. But what are the real outcomes when this trust is violated? Self-defense law provides a framework for analyzing tangible failure scenarios that can inform the design of robots and their algorithms. Studying self-defense is particularly important for ground robots since they operate within public environments, where they can pose a legitimate threat to the safety of nearby humans. Moreover, even if ground robots can guarantee human safety, the perception of a physical threat is sufficient to justify human self-defense against robots. In this paper, we synthesize works in law, engineering, and social science to present four actionable recommendations for how the robotics community can craft robots to mitigate the likelihood of self-defense situations arising. We establish how current U.S. self-defense law can justify a human protecting themselves against a robot, discuss the current literature on human attitudes toward robots, and analyze methods that have been produced to allow robots to operate close to humans. Finally, we present hypothetical scenarios that underscore how current robot navigation methods can fail to sufficiently consider self-defense concerns and the need for the recommendations to guide improvements in the field.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑