基础模型与合理使用
Foundation Models and Fair Use
摘要:
现有的基础模型是在受版权保护的材料上训练的。当数据创建者无法获得适当的归因或补偿时,部署这些模型可能会带来法律和道德风险。在美国和其他几个国家,受版权保护的内容可以用于构建基础模型,而不会因合理使用原则而承担责任。然而,有一个警告:如果模型产生的输出类似于受版权保护的数据,特别是在影响该数据市场的情况下,合理使用可能不再适用于模型的输出。在这项工作中,我们强调,合理使用是不能保证的,可能需要额外的工作来保持模型的开发和部署在合理使用的领域。首先,我们调查了基于版权内容开发和部署基础模型的潜在风险。我们回顾相关的美国案例法,绘制平行现有的和潜在的应用程序生成文本,源代码,和视觉art.Experiments证实,流行的基础模型可以生成内容相当类似的版权材料。其次,我们讨论了技术缓解措施,可以帮助基础模型保持合理使用。我们认为,需要进行更多的研究,以使缓解策略与当前的法律状况保持一致。最后,我们建议法律和技术缓解措施应共同发展。例如,与其他政策机制相结合,法律可以更明确地考虑在使用强大的技术工具来减轻侵权损害时的安全港。这种共同发展可能有助于在知识产权和创新之间取得平衡,这符合合理使用的最初目标。但我们强调,我们在这里描述的战略不是灵丹妙药,需要做更多的工作来制定政策,解决基础模型的潜在危害。
英文摘要:
Existing foundation models are trained on copyrighted material. Deploying these models can pose both legal and ethical risks when data creators fail to receive appropriate attribution or compensation. In the United States and several other countries, copyrighted content may be used to build foundation models without incurring liability due to the fair use doctrine. However, there is a caveat: If the model produces output that is similar to copyrighted data, particularly in scenarios that affect the market of that data, fair use may no longer apply to the output of the model. In this work, we emphasize that fair use is not guaranteed, and additional work may be necessary to keep model development and deployment squarely in the realm of fair use. First, we survey the potential risks of developing and deploying foundation models based on copyrighted content. We review relevant U.S. case law, drawing parallels to existing and potential applications for generating text, source code, and visual art. Experiments confirm that popular foundation models can generate content considerably similar to copyrighted material. Second, we discuss technical mitigations that can help foundation models stay in line with fair use. We argue that more research is needed to align mitigation strategies with the current state of the law. Lastly, we suggest that the law and technical mitigations should co-evolve. For example, coupled with other policy mechanisms, the law could more explicitly consider safe harbors when strong technical tools are used to mitigate infringement harms. This co-evolution may help strike a balance between intellectual property and innovation, which speaks to the original goal of fair use. But we emphasize that the strategies we describe here are not a panacea and more work is needed to develop policies that address the potential harms of foundation models.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。