实践中的公平投票
Fair votes in practice
摘要:
近年来,对良好投票制度的标准进行了特别仔细的审查,普遍认为核心价值观是公平结果、选民权力和选择以及地方代表性。本文重新审视了三种广泛使用的投票制度,单一可转移投票,名单PR,混合成员比例(MMP)的基本思想,并评估其性能的原则和实践。它特别仔细地审视了相称性,审查了三个方面:线性、代表性的门槛和获得多数的门槛。至于地区代表性,一个重要的问题是如何设计多人选区。有人认为,使用基于自然人口边界(如地方政府地区)的选区,可以将更好的地方代表性与长期稳定性和更好的比例性结合起来。STV无疑是最适合选民赋权和选择的,因为这些是其基本理念的一部分。论文第1页的摘要中总结了广泛的结论。本文利用最近公开的大型优惠投票数据集STV选举,使新的分析STV如何在实践中发挥作用,选民的行为,特别是研究选民的第二偏好如何与他们的第一偏好。
英文摘要:
Criteria for a good voting system have been given particularly careful scrutiny in recent years, with general agreement that the core values are fair results, voter power and choice, and local representation. This paper reexamines the basic ideas of three widely used voting systems, the Single Transferable Vote, List-PR, and Mixed Member Proportional (MMP); and evaluates their performance in terms of both principles and practice. It looks particularly closely at proportionality, examining three aspects:n linearity, the threshold for representation and the threshold for gaining a majority. As regards local representation, an important question is how to design multi-member constituencies. It will be argued that using constituencies based on natural demographic boundaries (such as local government areas) can combine better local representation with stability over time and better proportionality. STV is unsurprisingly best for voter empowerment and choice, as those are parts of its basic idea. Broad conclusions are summarised within the Summary on page 1 of the paper. The paper makes use of recent public availability of large preferential voting data sets for STV elections, making possible new analyses of how STV functions in practice, and of voter behaviour, particularly examining how voters' second preferences relate to their first preferences.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。