用于指导机构层面AI研究与应用的多领域关系框架
A multidomain relational framework to guide institutional AI research and adoption
AI总结:
针对当前AI机构应用研究中概念孤立、关联不足的问题,本文提出含运营、认知、规范三大横向领域的多领域关系框架,为跨领域AI研究与政策制定提供术语组织工具。
摘要:
当前,呼吁制定新的指标、技术标准与治理机制以指导人工智能(AI)在机构和公共管理领域应用的声音已十分普遍。然而,大多数旨在理解AI应用影响的研究与政策工作往往仅优先考虑少数几个方向,并未将所有潜在相关的不同视角与主题充分关联起来。在这篇立场论文中,我们认为这种缺失部分源于我们所称的社会技术话语中的关系问题:基本的本体论问题尚未得到解决——包括语义歧义、概念间缺乏明确关联,以及标准术语不统一。这导致评估机构级AI系统的推理模式始终各不相同,也使得研究这类系统的领域(包括机器学习ML、人因工程、社会科学与政策)普遍存在概念孤立的问题。在提出这一批判后,我们提出了一种推进路径:设计了一个概念框架形式的简易政策与研究设计工具,用于跨领域梳理术语——该框架包含三个用于归类相关概念与对应方法的横向领域:运营层(Operational)、认知层(Epistemic)与规范层(Normative)。我们首先结合AIES与FAccT这两个顶尖学术会议近期的社会技术研究话语背景,对该框架进行定位,随后举例说明如何通过在每个领域中落地相关概念,来助力制定合适的指标、标准与机制。最后,我们概述了发展这种面向机构AI研究与应用的关系式方法有待解决的问题。
英文摘要:
Calls for new metrics, technical standards and governance mechanisms to guide the adoption of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in institutions and public administration are now commonplace. Yet, most research and policy efforts aimed at understanding the implications of adopting AI tend to prioritize only a handful of ideas; they do not fully connect all the different perspectives and topics that are potentially relevant. In this position paper, we contend that this omission stems, in part, from what we call the relational problem in socio-technical discourse: fundamental ontological issues have not yet been settled--including semantic ambiguity, a lack of clear relations between concepts and differing standard terminologies. This contributes to the persistence of disparate modes of reasoning to assess institutional AI systems, and the prevalence of conceptual isolation in the fields that study them including ML, human factors, social science and policy. After developing this critique, we offer a way forward by proposing a simple policy and research design tool in the form of a conceptual framework to organize terms across fields--consisting of three horizontal domains for grouping relevant concepts and related methods: Operational, Epistemic, and Normative. We first situate this framework against the backdrop of recent socio-technical discourse at two premier academic venues, AIES and FAccT, before illustrating how developing suitable metrics, standards, and mechanisms can be aided by operationalizing relevant concepts in each of these domains. Finally, we outline outstanding questions for developing this relational approach to institutional AI research and adoption.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。