arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2303.02028cs.AIquant-ph
收藏

量子决策理论的校准:对大损失的厌恶和概率选择的可预测性

Calibration of Quantum Decision Theory: Aversion to Large Losses and Predictability of Probabilistic Choices

ETH Zürich(苏黎世联邦理工学院);Joint Institute for Nuclear Research(联合核研究所);Swiss Finance Institute(瑞士金融研究所);University of Geneva(日内瓦大学);Southern University of Science and Technology(南方科技大学)

T. Kovalenko, S. Vincent, V. I. Yukalov, D. Sornette

摘要:

我们提出了第一个校准的量子决策理论(QDT)的二元风险选择的数据集。我们定量占两个重复的实验之间的选择逆转的分数,使用概率选择配方在最简单的形式,没有模型假设或可调参数。然后,通过将决策者区分为两组:“多数派”和"逆向派“(比例为3:1),引入决策者之间的异质性,来改进对选择逆转的预测。这支持了QDT的第一个基本原则,它将选择建模为一个固有的概率过程,其中前景的概率可以表示为其效用和吸引力因素的总和。我们建议参数化的效用因子与随机版本的累积前景理论(logit-CPT),和吸引力因子与恒定的绝对风险厌恶(CARA)功能。对于这个数据集,并通过嵌套假设的Wilks检验惩罚大量的QDT参数,发现QDT模型在总体和个体水平上的表现明显优于logit-CPT,并且对于第一次实验迭代和预测(第二次"样本外“迭代)的所有考虑的拟合标准。由吸引因子捕获的独特QDT效应是最明显的(即,最相关和最强的幅度)的前景与大的损失。我们对实验结果的定量分析支持可预测性存在固有限制,这与选择的固有概率性质有关。本文的研究结果可以应用于人类决策者的选择预测以及人工智能的运行组织。

英文摘要:

We present the first calibration of quantum decision theory (QDT) to a dataset of binary risky choice. We quantitatively account for the fraction of choice reversals between two repetitions of the experiment, using a probabilistic choice formulation in the simplest form without model assumption or adjustable parameters. The prediction of choice reversal is then refined by introducing heterogeneity between decision makers through their differentiation into two groups: ``majoritarian'' and ``contrarian'' (in proportion 3:1). This supports the first fundamental tenet of QDT, which models choice as an inherent probabilistic process, where the probability of a prospect can be expressed as the sum of its utility and attraction factors. We propose to parameterise the utility factor with a stochastic version of cumulative prospect theory (logit-CPT), and the attraction factor with a constant absolute risk aversion (CARA) function. For this dataset, and penalising the larger number of QDT parameters via the Wilks test of nested hypotheses, the QDT model is found to perform significantly better than logit-CPT at both the aggregate and individual levels, and for all considered fit criteria for the first experiment iteration and for predictions (second ``out-of-sample'' iteration). The distinctive QDT effect captured by the attraction factor is mostly appreciable (i.e., most relevant and strongest in amplitude) for prospects with big losses. Our quantitative analysis of the experimental results supports the existence of an intrinsic limit of predictability, which is associated with the inherent probabilistic nature of choice. The results of the paper can find applications both in the prediction of choice of human decision makers as well as for organizing the operation of artificial intelligence.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑