arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2303.00738cs.CRcs.CYcs.HC
收藏

什么是机会?差分隐私中Eppery参数的解释

What Are the Chances? Explaining the Epsilon Parameter in Differential Privacy

Priyanka Nanayakkara, Mary Anne Smart, Rachel Cummings, Gabriel Kaptchuk, Elissa Redmiles

摘要:

差分隐私(DP)是一个数学隐私概念,越来越多地部署在政府和行业。使用DP,隐私保护是概率性的:它们受隐私预算参数$ε$的限制。之前在健康和计算科学方面的工作发现,人们很难推理概率风险。然而,将$ε$的含义传达给贡献数据的人,对于避免隐私戏剧(将毫无意义的隐私保护表现为有意义)和授权更明智的数据共享决策至关重要。借鉴风险沟通和可用性方面的最佳实践,我们开发了三种方法来向最终用户传达概率DP保证:两种方法用于传达赔率,一种方法提供DP输出的具体示例。我们定量评估这些解释方法在一个小插曲调查研究($n=963$)通过三个指标:客观的风险理解,DP保证的主观隐私理解,自我效能。我们发现,基于概率的解释方法比(1)基于输出的方法和(2)掩盖有关$ε$的信息的最先进的方法更有效。此外,当提供有关$ε$的信息时,受访者比提供最先进的DP解释时更愿意分享他们的数据;这种分享意愿对$ε$价值观很敏感:随着隐私保护减弱,受访者不太可能分享数据。

英文摘要:

Differential privacy (DP) is a mathematical privacy notion increasingly deployed across government and industry. With DP, privacy protections are probabilistic: they are bounded by the privacy budget parameter, $ε$. Prior work in health and computational science finds that people struggle to reason about probabilistic risks. Yet, communicating the implications of $ε$ to people contributing their data is vital to avoiding privacy theater -- presenting meaningless privacy protection as meaningful -- and empowering more informed data-sharing decisions. Drawing on best practices in risk communication and usability, we develop three methods to convey probabilistic DP guarantees to end users: two that communicate odds and one offering concrete examples of DP outputs. We quantitatively evaluate these explanation methods in a vignette survey study ($n=963$) via three metrics: objective risk comprehension, subjective privacy understanding of DP guarantees, and self-efficacy. We find that odds-based explanation methods are more effective than (1) output-based methods and (2) state-of-the-art approaches that gloss over information about $ε$. Further, when offered information about $ε$, respondents are more willing to share their data than when presented with a state-of-the-art DP explanation; this willingness to share is sensitive to $ε$ values: as privacy protections weaken, respondents are less likely to share data.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑