用于研究禽流感病毒传播和控制的机制模型的系统评价
A systematic review of mechanistic models used to study avian influenza virus transmission and control
摘要:
禽流感病毒在家禽中的全球传播正在造成巨大的经济和社会损失。为了更好地了解禽流感的传播和评估控制措施的有效性,已经开发了各种机制模型。然而,目前还没有对使用的机械方法进行全面审查。为了帮助填补这一空白,我们对应用于现实世界流行病的机制模型进行了系统性综述,以(1)描述模型类型及其流行病学背景,(2)综合AIV传播参数的估计值,(3)审查最常评估的控制策略及其结果。45篇符合纳入条件的文章,将模型拟合到数据和估计参数值(n = 42)和/或评价控制策略的有效性(n = 21)。大多数是基于群体的模型(n = 26),其次是基于个体的模型(n = 15)和少数集合群体模型(n = 4)。传播率的估计值因流行病学背景、病毒亚型和流行病学单位的不同而有很大差异。其他参数,如潜伏期和传染期的持续时间更频繁地假设,限制了这些机制模型带来的见解。关于控制策略,许多模型评估了剔除(n = 15),而疫苗接种受到较少关注(n = 7)。根据综述的文章,最佳控制策略因病毒亚型和当地条件而异,也取决于目标。例如,当目标是限制扑杀鸡群的总数时,疫苗接种是最佳的,而先发制人的扑杀则是减少流行规模和持续时间的首选。及早实施干预措施不断提高控制战略的效力,突出表明需要进行有效的监测和流行病防范。机制模型的潜在改进包括明确说明各种传播途径,并根据物种和农场类型区分家禽种群。为了及时为政策制定者提供见解,值得进一步关注的控制策略评估方面包括:经济评估,包括疫苗接种在内的策略组合,使用优化算法而不是比较有限的一组场景,以及实时评估。
英文摘要:
The global spread of avian influenza A viruses in domestic birds is causing dramatic economic and social losses. Various mechanistic models have been developed in an attempt to better understand avian influenza transmission and to evaluate the effectiveness of control measures. However, no comprehensive review of the mechanistic approaches used currently exists. To help fill this gap, we conducted a systematic review of mechanistic models applied to real-world epidemics to (1) describe the type of models and their epidemiological context, (2) synthetise estimated values of AIV transmission parameters and (3) review the control strategies most frequently evaluated and their outcome. Fourty-five articles qualified for inclusion, that fitted the model to data and estimated parameter values (n = 42) and/or evaluated the effectiveness of control strategies (n = 21). The majority were population-based models (n = 26), followed by individual-based models (n = 15) and a few metapopulation models (n = 4). Estimated values for the transmission rate varied substantially according to epidemiological settings, virus subtypes and epidemiological units. Other parameters such as the durations of the latent and infectious periods were more frequently assumed, limiting the insights brought by mechanistic models on these. Concerning control strategies, many models evaluated culling (n = 15), while vaccination received less attention (n = 7). According to the reviewed articles, optimal control strategies varied between virus subtypes and local conditions, and also depended on the objective. For instance, vaccination was optimal when the objective was to limit the overall number of culled flocks, while pre-emptive culling was preferred for reducing the epidemic size and duration. Earlier implementation of interventions consistently improved the efficacy of control strategies, highlighting the need for effective surveillance and epidemic preparedness. Potential improvements of mechanistic models include explicitly accounting for various transmission routes, and distinguishing poultry populations according to species and farm type. To provide insights to policy makers in a timely manner, aspects about the evaluation of control strategies that could deserve further attention include: economic evaluation, combination of strategies including vaccination, the use of optimization algorithm instead of comparing a limited set of scenarios, and real-time evaluation.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。