Graph-based Knowledge Distillation: A survey and experimental evaluation
Institute of Computing Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences（中国科学院计算技术研究所）；Zhejiang University（浙江大学）；China University of Geosciences (Beijing)（中国地质大学（北京））
Graph, such as citation networks, social networks, and transportation networks, are prevalent in the real world. Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have gained widespread attention for their robust expressiveness and exceptional performance in various graph applications. However, the efficacy of GNNs is heavily reliant on sufficient data labels and complex network models, with the former obtaining hardly and the latter computing costly. To address the labeled data scarcity and high complexity of GNNs, Knowledge Distillation (KD) has been introduced to enhance existing GNNs. This technique involves transferring the soft-label supervision of the large teacher model to the small student model while maintaining prediction performance. This survey offers a comprehensive overview of Graph-based Knowledge Distillation methods, systematically categorizing and summarizing them while discussing their limitations and future directions. This paper first introduces the background of graph and KD. It then provides a comprehensive summary of three types of Graph-based Knowledge Distillation methods, namely Graph-based Knowledge Distillation for deep neural networks (DKD), Graph-based Knowledge Distillation for GNNs (GKD), and Self-Knowledge Distillation based Graph-based Knowledge Distillation (SKD). Each type is further divided into knowledge distillation methods based on the output layer, middle layer, and constructed graph. Subsequently, various algorithms' ideas are analyzed and compared, concluding with the advantages and disadvantages of each algorithm supported by experimental results. In addition, the applications of graph-based knowledge distillation in CV, NLP, RS, and other fields are listed. Finally, the graph-based knowledge distillation is summarized and prospectively discussed. We have also released related resources at https://github.com/liujing1023/Graph-based-Knowledge-Distillation.
We survey various knowledge distillation (KD) strategies for simple classification tasks and implement a set of techniques that claim state-of-the-art accuracy. Our experiments using standardized model architectures, fixed compute budgets, and consistent training schedules indicate that many of these distillation results are hard to reproduce. This is especially apparent with methods using some form of feature distillation. Further examination reveals a lack of generalizability where these techniques may only succeed for specific architectures and training settings. We observe that appropriate…
DIT Center, Samsung Electronics（三星电子DIT中心）；ECE & ASRI, Seoul National University（首尔大学电子与计算机工程系及自动化与系统研究所）
We propose a novel knowledge distillation approach to facilitate the transfer of dark knowledge from a teacher to a student. Contrary to most of the existing methods that rely on effective training of student models given pretrained teachers, we aim to learn the teacher models that are friendly to students and, consequently, more appropriate for knowledge transfer. In other words, at the time of optimizing a teacher model, the proposed algorithm learns the student branches jointly to obtain student-friendly representations. Since the main goal of our approach lies in training teacher models an…
CLOVA AI Research, NAVER Corp.（NAVER公司CLOVA人工智能研究院）
Knowledge distillation extracts general knowledge from a pre-trained teacher network and provides guidance to a target student network. Most studies manually tie intermediate features of the teacher and student, and transfer knowledge through pre-defined links. However, manual selection often constructs ineffective links that limit the improvement from the distillation. There has been an attempt to address the problem, but it is still challenging to identify effective links under practical scenarios. In this paper, we introduce an effective and efficient feature distillation method utilizing a…
Institute of Information Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences（中国科学院信息工程研究所）；School of Cyber Security, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences（中国科学院大学网络空间安全学院）；Department of Communication Engineering, Shanghai University（上海大学通信工程学院）
Knowledge distillation provides an effective way to transfer knowledge via teacher-student learning, where most existing distillation approaches apply a fixed pre-trained model as teacher to supervise the learning of student network. This manner usually brings in a big capability gap between teacher and student networks during learning. Recent researches have observed that a small teacher-student capability gap can facilitate knowledge transfer. Inspired by that, we propose an evolutionary knowledge distillation approach to improve the transfer effectiveness of teacher knowledge. Instead of a …
Deep neural networks (DNNs) have been extremely successful in solving many challenging AI tasks in natural language processing, speech recognition, and computer vision nowadays. However, DNNs are typically computation intensive, memory demanding, and power hungry, which significantly limits their usage on platforms with constrained resources. Therefore, a variety of compression techniques (e.g. quantization, pruning, and knowledge distillation) have been proposed to reduce the size and power consumption of DNNs. Blockwise knowledge distillation is one of the compression techniques that can eff…
This paper aims to provide a selective survey about knowledge distillation(KD) framework for researchers and practitioners to take advantage of it for developing new optimized models in the deep neural network field. To this end, we give a brief overview of knowledge distillation and some related works including learning using privileged information(LUPI) and generalized distillation(GD). Even though knowledge distillation based on the teacher-student architecture was initially devised as a model compression technique, it has found versatile applications over various frameworks. In this paper,…
King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals（法赫德国王石油与矿产大学）
Deep learning based models are relatively large, and it is hard to deploy such models on resource-limited devices such as mobile phones and embedded devices. One possible solution is knowledge distillation whereby a smaller model (student model) is trained by utilizing the information from a larger model (teacher model). In this paper, we present a survey of knowledge distillation techniques applied to deep learning models. To compare the performances of different techniques, we propose a new metric called distillation metric. Distillation metric compares different knowledge distillation algor…
Stanford University（斯坦福大学）；Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne（洛桑联邦理工学院）
We study the use of knowledge distillation to compress the U-net architecture. We show that, while standard distillation is not sufficient to reliably train a compressed U-net, introducing other regularization methods, such as batch normalization and class re-weighting, in knowledge distillation significantly improves the training process. This allows us to compress a U-net by over 1000x, i.e., to 0.1% of its original number of parameters, at a negligible decrease in performance.
Knowledge Distillation is becoming one of the primary trends among neural network compression algorithms to improve the generalization performance of a smaller student model with guidance from a larger teacher model. This momentous rise in applications of knowledge distillation is accompanied by the introduction of numerous algorithms for distilling the knowledge such as soft targets and hint layers. Despite this advancement in different techniques for distilling the knowledge, the aggregation of different paths for distillation has not been studied comprehensively. This is of particular signi…
University of Science and Technology of China（中国科学技术大学）；Sun Yat-sen University（中山大学）
Knowledge distillation is to transfer the knowledge from the data learned by the teacher network to the student network, so that the student has the advantage of less parameters and less calculations, and the accuracy is close to the teacher. In this paper, we propose a new distillation method, which contains two transfer distillation strategies and a loss decay strategy. The first transfer strategy is based on channel-wise attention, called Channel Distillation (CD). CD transfers the channel information from the teacher to the student. The second is Guided Knowledge Distillation (GKD). Unlike…
Knowledge distillation aims to transfer knowledge to the student model by utilizing the predictions/features of the teacher model, and feature-based distillation has recently shown its superiority over logit-based distillation. However, due to the cumbersome computation and storage of extra feature transformation, the training overhead of feature-based methods is much higher than that of logit-based distillation. In this work, we revisit the logit-based knowledge distillation, and observe that the existing logit-based distillation methods treat the prediction logits only in the instance level,…
Traditional knowledge distillation transfers "dark knowledge" of a pre-trained teacher network to a student network, and ignores the knowledge in the training process of the teacher, which we call teacher's experience. However, in realistic educational scenarios, learning experience is often more important than learning results. In this work, we propose a novel knowledge distillation method by integrating the teacher's experience for knowledge transfer, named experience ensemble knowledge distillation (EEKD). We save a moderate number of intermediate models from the training process of the tea…
Knowledge Distillation (KD) transfers the knowledge from a high-capacity teacher model to promote a smaller student model. Existing efforts guide the distillation by matching their prediction logits, feature embedding, etc., while leaving how to efficiently utilize them in junction less explored. In this paper, we propose Hint-dynamic Knowledge Distillation, dubbed HKD, which excavates the knowledge from the teacher' s hints in a dynamic scheme. The guidance effect from the knowledge hints usually varies in different instances and learning stages, which motivates us to customize a specific hin…
Knowledge distillation (KD) is an effective framework to transfer knowledge from a large-scale teacher to a compact yet well-performing student. Previous KD practices for pre-trained language models mainly transfer knowledge by aligning instance-wise outputs between the teacher and student, while neglecting an important knowledge source, i.e., the gradient of the teacher. The gradient characterizes how the teacher responds to changes in inputs, which we assume is beneficial for the student to better approximate the underlying mapping function of the teacher. Therefore, we propose Gradient Know…
To put a state-of-the-art neural network to practical use, it is necessary to design a model that has a good trade-off between the resource consumption and performance on the test set. Many researchers and engineers are developing methods that enable training or designing a model more efficiently. Developing an efficient model includes several strategies such as network architecture search, pruning, quantization, knowledge distillation, utilizing cheap convolution, regularization, and also includes any craft that leads to a better performance-resource trade-off. When combining these technologi…
Tsinghua University（清华大学）；Microsoft Research Asia（微软亚洲研究院）
Ensemble knowledge distillation can extract knowledge from multiple teacher models and encode it into a single student model. Many existing methods learn and distill the student model on labeled data only. However, the teacher models are usually learned on the same labeled data, and their predictions have high correlations with groudtruth labels. Thus, they cannot provide sufficient knowledge complementary to task labels for student teaching. Distilling on unseen unlabeled data has the potential to enhance the knowledge transfer from the teachers to the student. In this paper, we propose a uni…
Adversarial training is the most promising method for learning robust models against adversarial examples. A recent study has shown that knowledge distillation between the same architectures is effective in improving the performance of adversarial training. Exploiting knowledge distillation is a new approach to improve adversarial training and has attracted much attention. However, its performance is still insufficient. Therefore, we propose Adversarial Robust Distillation with Internal Representation~(ARDIR) to utilize knowledge distillation even more effectively. In addition to the output of…
In this paper, we present a thorough evaluation of the efficacy of knowledge distillation and its dependence on student and teacher architectures. Starting with the observation that more accurate teachers often don't make good teachers, we attempt to tease apart the factors that affect knowledge distillation performance. We find crucially that larger models do not often make better teachers. We show that this is a consequence of mismatched capacity, and that small students are unable to mimic large teachers. We find typical ways of circumventing this (such as performing a sequence of knowledge…
Knowledge distillation aims at transferring knowledge acquired in one model (a teacher) to another model (a student) that is typically smaller. Previous approaches can be expressed as a form of training the student to mimic output activations of individual data examples represented by the teacher. We introduce a novel approach, dubbed relational knowledge distillation (RKD), that transfers mutual relations of data examples instead. For concrete realizations of RKD, we propose distance-wise and angle-wise distillation losses that penalize structural differences in relations. Experiments conduct…
Stanford University（斯坦福大学）；Microsoft Research, New England（微软研究院新英格兰分院）
A popular approach to model compression is to train an inexpensive student model to mimic the class probabilities of a highly accurate but cumbersome teacher model. Surprisingly, this two-step knowledge distillation process often leads to higher accuracy than training the student directly on labeled data. To explain and enhance this phenomenon, we cast knowledge distillation as a semiparametric inference problem with the optimal student model as the target, the unknown Bayes class probabilities as nuisance, and the teacher probabilities as a plug-in nuisance estimate. By adapting modern semipa…
To circumvent the non-parallelizability of recurrent neural network-based equalizers, we propose knowledge distillation to recast the RNN into a parallelizable feedforward structure. The latter shows 38\% latency decrease, while impacting the Q-factor by only 0.5dB.
In recent years, knowledge distillation has become a cornerstone of efficiently deployed machine learning, with labs and industries using knowledge distillation to train models that are inexpensive and resource-optimized. Trojan attacks have contemporaneously gained significant prominence, revealing fundamental vulnerabilities in deep learning models. Given the widespread use of knowledge distillation, in this work we seek to exploit the unlabelled data knowledge distillation process to embed Trojans in a student model without introducing conspicuous behavior in the teacher. We ultimately devi…
Shanghai Jiao Tong University（上海交通大学）；Huazhong University of Science & Technology（华中科技大学）；Xi’an Jiaotong University（西安交通大学）
This paper presents a method to interpret the success of knowledge distillation by quantifying and analyzing task-relevant and task-irrelevant visual concepts that are encoded in intermediate layers of a deep neural network (DNN). More specifically, three hypotheses are proposed as follows. 1. Knowledge distillation makes the DNN learn more visual concepts than learning from raw data. 2. Knowledge distillation ensures that the DNN is prone to learning various visual concepts simultaneously. Whereas, in the scenario of learning from raw data, the DNN learns visual concepts sequentially. 3. Know…
Ludwig Maximilian Muenchen Unitversitaet（慕尼黑路德维希-马克西米利安大学）
Although deep neural networks have shown well-performance in various tasks, the poor interpretability of the models is always criticized. In the paper, we propose a new interpretable neural network method, by embedding neurons into the semantic space to extract their intrinsic global semantics. In contrast to previous methods that probe latent knowledge inside the model, the proposed semantic vector externalizes the latent knowledge to static knowledge, which is easy to exploit. Specifically, we assume that neurons with similar activation are of similar semantic information. Afterwards, semant…
The remarkable breakthroughs in point cloud representation learning have boosted their usage in real-world applications such as self-driving cars and virtual reality. However, these applications usually have an urgent requirement for not only accurate but also efficient 3D object detection. Recently, knowledge distillation has been proposed as an effective model compression technique, which transfers the knowledge from an over-parameterized teacher to a lightweight student and achieves consistent effectiveness in 2D vision. However, due to point clouds' sparsity and irregularity, directly appl…
Pixel Distillation: A New Knowledge Distillation Scheme for Low-Resolution Image Recognition
Northwestern Polytechnical University（西北工业大学）；Xijing Hospital, The Fourth Military Medical University（第四军医大学西京医院）；Beijing Technology And Business University（北京工商大学）；Mohamed bin Zayed University of Artificial Intelligence（穆罕默德·本·扎耶德人工智能大学）；Nankai University（南开大学）；Hefei Comprehensive National Science Center（合肥综合性国家科学中心）
Knowledge distillation (KD) has become a well established paradigm for compressing deep neural networks. The typical way of conducting knowledge distillation is to train the student network under the supervision of the teacher network to harness the knowledge at one or multiple spots (i.e., layers) in the teacher network. The distillation spots, once specified, will not change for all the training samples, throughout the whole distillation process. In this work, we argue that distillation spots should be adaptive to training samples and distillation epochs. We thus propose a new distillation s…
Recent recommender systems have started to employ knowledge distillation, which is a model compression technique distilling knowledge from a cumbersome model (teacher) to a compact model (student), to reduce inference latency while maintaining performance. The state-of-the-art methods have only focused on making the student model accurately imitate the predictions of the teacher model. They have a limitation in that the prediction results incompletely reveal the teacher's knowledge. In this paper, we propose a novel knowledge distillation framework for recommender system, called DE-RRD, which …
Compared to traditional learning from scratch, knowledge distillation sometimes makes the DNN achieve superior performance. This paper provides a new perspective to explain the success of knowledge distillation, i.e., quantifying knowledge points encoded in intermediate layers of a DNN for classification, based on the information theory. To this end, we consider the signal processing in a DNN as the layer-wise information discarding. A knowledge point is referred to as an input unit, whose information is much less discarded than other input units. Thus, we propose three hypotheses for knowledg…
Despite the success of Deep Learning (DL), the deployment of modern DL models requiring large computational power poses a significant problem for resource-constrained systems. This necessitates building compact networks that reduce computations while preserving performance. Traditional Knowledge Distillation (KD) methods that transfer knowledge from teacher to student (a) use a single-stage and (b) require the whole data set while distilling the knowledge to the student. In this work, we propose a new method called Stagewise Knowledge Distillation (SKD) which builds on traditional KD methods b…
Uncertainty-Aware Dual-Student Knowledge Distillation for Efficient Image Classification
Department of Electrical Engineering Indian Institute of Technology Bombay 21D070002（电子工程系 印度理工学院班加罗尔 21D070002）；Department of Electrical Engineering Indian Institute of Technology Bombay 210010010（电子工程系 印度理工学院班加罗尔 210010010）；Department of Electrical Engineering Indian Institute of Technology Bombay 210020023（电子工程系 印度理工学院班加罗尔 210020023）
The University of Sydney（悉尼大学）；Birkbeck College, University of London（伦敦大学伯贝克学院）；UBTECH（优必选）
In recent years, deep neural networks have been successful in both industry and academia, especially for computer vision tasks. The great success of deep learning is mainly due to its scalability to encode large-scale data and to maneuver billions of model parameters. However, it is a challenge to deploy these cumbersome deep models on devices with limited resources, e.g., mobile phones and embedded devices, not only because of the high computational complexity but also the large storage requirements. To this end, a variety of model compression and acceleration techniques have been developed. …
Federated learning (FL), which utilizes communication between the server (core) and local devices (edges) to indirectly learn from more data, is an emerging field in deep learning research. Recently, Knowledge Distillation-based FL methods with notable performance and high applicability have been suggested. In this paper, we choose knowledge distillation-based FL method as our baseline and tackle a challenging problem that ensues from using these methods. Especially, we focus on the problem incurred in the server model that tries to mimic different datasets, each of which is unique to an indiv…
The performance of autoregressive models on natural language generation tasks has dramatically improved due to the adoption of deep, self-attentive architectures. However, these gains have come at the cost of hindering inference speed, making state-of-the-art models cumbersome to deploy in real-world, time-sensitive settings. We develop a compression technique for autoregressive models that is driven by an imitation learning perspective on knowledge distillation. The algorithm is designed to address the exposure bias problem. On prototypical language generation tasks such as translation and su…
Knowledge distillation is initially introduced to utilize additional supervision from a single teacher model for the student model training. To boost the student performance, some recent variants attempt to exploit diverse knowledge sources from multiple teachers. However, existing studies mainly integrate knowledge from diverse sources by averaging over multiple teacher predictions or combining them using other various label-free strategies, which may mislead student in the presence of low-quality teacher predictions. To tackle this problem, we propose Confidence-Aware Multi-teacher Knowledge…
Zhejiang University（浙江大学）；ZJU-LianlianPay Joint Research Center（浙江大学-连连支付联合研究中心）；Zhejiang University of Technology（浙江工业大学）
Distillation is an effective knowledge-transfer technique that uses predicted distributions of a powerful teacher model as soft targets to train a less-parameterized student model. A pre-trained high capacity teacher, however, is not always available. Recently proposed online variants use the aggregated intermediate predictions of multiple student models as targets to train each student model. Although group-derived targets give a good recipe for teacher-free distillation, group members are homogenized quickly with simple aggregation functions, leading to early saturated solutions. In this wor…
Entity alignment aims at integrating heterogeneous knowledge from different knowledge graphs. Recent studies employ embedding-based methods by first learning the representation of Knowledge Graphs and then performing entity alignment via measuring the similarity between entity embeddings. However, they failed to make good use of the relation semantic information due to the trade-off problem caused by the different objectives of learning knowledge embedding and neighborhood consensus. To address this problem, we propose Relational Knowledge Distillation for Entity Alignment (RKDEA), a Graph Con…
Knowledge distillation is a standard teacher-student learning framework to train a light-weight student network under the guidance of a well-trained large teacher network. As an effective teaching strategy, interactive teaching has been widely employed at school to motivate students, in which teachers not only provide knowledge but also give constructive feedback to students upon their responses, to improve their learning performance. In this work, we propose an InterActive Knowledge Distillation (IAKD) scheme to leverage the interactive teaching strategy for efficient knowledge distillation. …
Microsoft Dynamics 365 AI Research（微软Dynamics 365人工智能研究院）
Pre-trained language models such as BERT have proven to be highly effective for natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, the high demand for computing resources in training such models hinders their application in practice. In order to alleviate this resource hunger in large-scale model training, we propose a Patient Knowledge Distillation approach to compress an original large model (teacher) into an equally-effective lightweight shallow network (student). Different from previous knowledge distillation methods, which only use the output from the last layer of the teacher network for …
Huawei Noah’s Ark Lab（华为诺亚方舟实验室）；University of British Columbia（英属哥伦比亚大学）
The advent of large pre-trained language models has given rise to rapid progress in the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP). While the performance of these models on standard benchmarks has scaled with size, compression techniques such as knowledge distillation have been key in making them practical. We present, MATE-KD, a novel text-based adversarial training algorithm which improves the performance of knowledge distillation. MATE-KD first trains a masked language model based generator to perturb text by maximizing the divergence between teacher and student logits. Then using knowledge…
State University of New York at Binghamton（纽约州立大学宾汉姆顿分校）
Knowledge distillation (KD) is an effective technique to transfer knowledge from one neural network (teacher) to another (student), thus improving the performance of the student. To make the student better mimic the behavior of the teacher, the existing work focuses on designing different criteria to align their logits or representations. Different from these efforts, we address knowledge distillation from a novel data perspective. We argue that transferring knowledge at sparse training data points cannot enable the student to well capture the local shape of the teacher function. To address th…
University of Waterloo（滑铁卢大学）；Salesforce Research（赛富时研究院）
Pretrained language models have led to significant performance gains in many NLP tasks. However, the intensive computing resources to train such models remain an issue. Knowledge distillation alleviates this problem by learning a light-weight student model. So far the distillation approaches are all task-specific. In this paper, we explore knowledge distillation under the multi-task learning setting. The student is jointly distilled across different tasks. It acquires more general representation capacity through multi-tasking distillation and can be further fine-tuned to improve the model in t…
