推荐系统中的放大悖论
The Amplification Paradox in Recommender Systems
AI总结:
本文通过基于智能体的模型揭示了推荐系统中的“放大悖论”,表明尽管算法偏好极端内容,但由于极端内容的小众性和低效用,用户很少消费,从而导致系统去放大此类内容,呼吁对算法放大进行细致解读。
摘要:
对推荐系统的自动化审计发现,盲目遵循推荐会导致用户越来越多地接触到党派化、阴谋论或虚假内容。同时,使用真实用户轨迹的研究表明,推荐系统并非驱动极端内容关注度的首要因素;相反,这类内容大多通过其他途径触达,例如其他网站。本文解释了以下明显的悖论:如果推荐算法偏好极端内容,为何它没有驱动其消费?通过一个基于智能体的简单模型(其中用户对推荐系统中的项目赋予不同效用),我们通过模拟表明,推荐系统的协同过滤特性和极端内容的小众性可以解决这一表面悖论:尽管盲目遵循推荐确实会将用户引向小众内容,但当用户有选择权时,他们很少消费小众内容,因为这些内容对他们效用低,这可导致推荐系统对此类内容进行去放大。我们的结果呼吁对“算法放大”进行细致解读,并强调在审计推荐系统时建模内容对用户效用的重要性。代码可用:https://github.com/epfl-dlab/amplification_paradox。
英文摘要:
Automated audits of recommender systems found that blindly following recommendations leads users to increasingly partisan, conspiratorial, or false content. At the same time, studies using real user traces suggest that recommender systems are not the primary driver of attention toward extreme content; on the contrary, such content is mostly reached through other means, e.g., other websites. In this paper, we explain the following apparent paradox: if the recommendation algorithm favors extreme content, why is it not driving its consumption? With a simple agent-based model where users attribute different utilities to items in the recommender system, we show through simulations that the collaborative-filtering nature of recommender systems and the nicheness of extreme content can resolve the apparent paradox: although blindly following recommendations would indeed lead users to niche content, users rarely consume niche content when given the option because it is of low utility to them, which can lead the recommender system to deamplify such content. Our results call for a nuanced interpretation of ``algorithmic amplification'' and highlight the importance of modeling the utility of content to users when auditing recommender systems. Code available: https://github.com/epfl-dlab/amplification_paradox.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。