什么是调查?天文学中的模拟诱导选择效应
What Is In a Survey? Simulation-Induced Selection Effects in Astronomy
摘要:
观测天文学受到选择效应的困扰,在解释来自天文调查的数据时必须考虑到这一点。由于观测时间和仪器灵敏度的物理限制,数据集很少完整。然而,确定任何样本中缺少的具体内容并不总是那么简单。例如,在任何亮度有限的样本中,暗天体(如星系)总是比亮天体多,但暗天体可能与亮天体不同。假设它们是可能导致错误地描述可以检测到的边界附近的对象群体。类似地,从可以很好地观察到的附近物体开始,假设更远的物体(从更年轻的宇宙中取样)是同一种物体,可能会让我们误入歧途。星系群的人口模型可以用作观测系统模拟的输入,以创建"模拟“目录,用于描述和解释多重相互作用的选择效应。为此目的使用模拟是天文学中的常见做法,模糊了观测和模拟之间的界限;观测数据不能独立于模拟进行解释。我们将描述这种方法,并认为天体物理学家已经开发出有效的方法来建立依赖于模拟的观测程序的可靠性。可靠性取决于模拟人口的物理和人口统计特性如何通过独立观察来约束。我们还确定了一个新的挑战所提出的使用模拟,我们称之为“问题的未计算的替代品。有时候,模拟本身会产生意想不到的选择效应,因为模拟的局限性导致天文学家只考虑有限的替代方案。
英文摘要:
Observational astronomy is plagued with selection effects that must be taken into account when interpreting data from astronomical surveys. Because of the physical limitations of observing time and instrument sensitivity, datasets are rarely complete. However, determining specifically what is missing from any sample is not always straightforward. For example, there are always more faint objects (such as galaxies) than bright ones in any brightness-limited sample, but faint objects may not be of the same kind as bright ones. Assuming they are can lead to mischaracterizing the population of objects near the boundary of what can be detected. Similarly, starting with nearby objects that can be well observed and assuming that objects much farther away (and sampled from a younger universe) are of the same kind can lead us astray. Demographic models of galaxy populations can be used as inputs to observing system simulations to create ``mock'' catalogues that can be used to characterize and account for multiple, interacting selection effects. The use of simulations for this purpose is common practice in astronomy, and blurs the line between observations and simulations; the observational data cannot be interpreted independent of the simulations. We will describe this methodology and argue that astrophysicists have developed effective ways to establish the reliability of simulation-dependent observational programs. The reliability depends on how well the physical and demographic properties of the simulated population can be constrained through independent observations. We also identify a new challenge raised by the use of simulations, which we call the ``problem of uncomputed alternatives.'' Sometimes the simulations themselves create unintended selection effects when the limits of what can be simulated lead astronomers to only consider a limited space of alternative proposals.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。