arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2302.10003cs.PL
收藏

程序设计系统的技术层面

Technical Dimensions of Programming Systems

Joel Jakubovic, Jonathan Edwards, Tomas Petricek

摘要:

编程需要的不仅仅是用程序设计语言编写代码。它通常在有状态环境的上下文中通过图形用户界面与系统交互来完成。然而,这个广阔的可能性空间缺乏一个共同的导航结构。关于编程系统的研究未能形成一个连贯的研究体系,这使得它很难在过去的工作基础上进行改进,也很难推动技术的发展。在计算机科学中,人们已经说了很多话,做了很多工作来比较 ** 程序设计语言 **,但对于 ** 编程系统 * 却没有类似的理论存在;我们认为编程系统也应该有一个理论。我们提出了一个框架的技术层面捕捉编程系统的基本特征,并提供了一种方法,概念化和比较它们。我们通过检查过去有影响力的编程系统,并审查其设计原则,技术能力和用户交互风格来确定技术维度。技术维度捕捉的是可以独立研究、比较和推进的特征。这使得以一种可以共享和建设性辩论的方式谈论编程系统成为可能,而不仅仅是依赖于个人印象。我们的框架是使用过去的编程系统的定性分析得出的。我们概述了使用我们框架的两种具体方式。首先,我们展示了它如何可以分析最近开发的新的编程系统。然后,我们用它来确定一个有趣的未开发的点在编程系统的设计空间。许多研究工作集中在构建更容易使用,非专家可以访问,可塑造和/或强大的编程系统,但这些努力是脱节的。它们是非正式的,以作者的个人观点为指导,因此只能根据使用它们的个人经验进行评价和比较。通过为更系统的研究提供基础,我们可以帮助编程系统研究人员最终站在巨人的肩膀上。

英文摘要:

Programming requires much more than just writing code in a programming language. It is usually done in the context of a stateful environment, by interacting with a system through a graphical user interface. Yet, this wide space of possibilities lacks a common structure for navigation. Work on programming systems fails to form a coherent body of research, making it hard to improve on past work and advance the state of the art. In computer science, much has been said and done to allow comparison of **programming languages**, yet no similar theory exists for *programming systems*; we believe that programming systems deserve a theory too. We present a framework of *technical dimensions* which capture the underlying characteristics of programming systems and provide a means for conceptualizing and comparing them. We identify technical dimensions by examining past influential programming systems and reviewing their design principles, technical capabilities, and styles of user interaction. Technical dimensions capture characteristics that may be studied, compared and advanced independently. This makes it possible to talk about programming systems in a way that can be shared and constructively debated rather than relying solely on personal impressions. Our framework is derived using a qualitative analysis of past programming systems. We outline two concrete ways of using our framework. First, we show how it can analyze a recently developed novel programming system. Then, we use it to identify an interesting unexplored point in the design space of programming systems. Much research effort focuses on building programming systems that are easier to use, accessible to non-experts, moldable and/or powerful, but such efforts are disconnected. They are informal, guided by the personal vision of their authors and thus are only evaluable and comparable on the basis of individual experience using them. By providing foundations for more systematic research, we can help programming systems researchers to stand, at last, on the shoulders of giants.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑