对Opodi等人《分子结的单能级隧穿模型:评估模拟方法》一文的评论
Comment on "A single level tunneling model for molecular junctions: evaluating the simulation methods" by Opodi et al
AI总结:
本评论指出Opodi等人论文中的“适用性图谱”存在事实错误:方法2在声称不适用的参数下偏差不超过3%,方法3的参数范围超出其适用界限。
摘要:
本评论指出了Opodi等人发表于《物理化学化学物理》2022年第24卷第11958页的论文中的重大缺陷。他们的核心成果(“适用性图谱”)旨在指明两种近似方法(称为方法2和方法3)适用的参数范围。我的计算表明,该适用性图谱存在事实性错误。在Opodi等人声称方法2不适用的模型参数下,I2与精确电流I1的偏差不超过3%。至于方法3,适用性图谱所涵盖的参数范围超出了其适用范围,这一点在Opodi等人自己引用的文献中已有说明。
英文摘要:
The present Comment demonstrates important flaws of the paper Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2022, 24, 11958 by Opodi~\emph{et al.} Their crown result (``applicability map'') aims at indicating parameter ranges wherein two approximate methods (called method 2 and 3) apply. My calculations reveal that the applicability map is a factual error. Deviations of $I_2$ from the exact current $I_1$ do not exceed 3\% for model parameters where Opodi~\emph{et al.} claimed that method 2 is inapplicable. As for method 3, the parameter range of the applicability map is beyond its scope, as stated in papers cited by Opodi~\emph{et al.}~themselves.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。