深度学习方法在分子构象生成中真的表现更好吗?
Do Deep Learning Methods Really Perform Better in Molecular Conformation Generation?
摘要:
分子构象生成(MCG)是药物发现中的一个基本而重要的问题.许多传统的方法已经发展到解决MCG问题,如系统搜索,建模,随机搜索,距离几何,分子动力学,蒙特卡罗方法等,但它们都有一些局限性取决于分子结构。最近,有很多基于深度学习的MCG方法,声称它们在很大程度上优于传统方法。然而,令我们惊讶的是,我们设计了一个简单而廉价的算法(无参数)的基础上的传统方法,并发现它是可比的,甚至优于深度学习为基础的MCG方法在广泛使用的GEOM-QM 9和GEOM-Drugs基准。特别是,我们的设计算法是简单的RDKIT生成的构象的聚类。我们希望我们的发现可以帮助社区修改MCG的深度学习方法。所提出的算法的代码可以在https://gist.github.com/ZhouGengmo/5b565f51adafcd911c0bc115b2ef027c上找到。
英文摘要:
Molecular conformation generation (MCG) is a fundamental and important problem in drug discovery. Many traditional methods have been developed to solve the MCG problem, such as systematic searching, model-building, random searching, distance geometry, molecular dynamics, Monte Carlo methods, etc. However, they have some limitations depending on the molecular structures. Recently, there are plenty of deep learning based MCG methods, which claim they largely outperform the traditional methods. However, to our surprise, we design a simple and cheap algorithm (parameter-free) based on the traditional methods and find it is comparable to or even outperforms deep learning based MCG methods in the widely used GEOM-QM9 and GEOM-Drugs benchmarks. In particular, our design algorithm is simply the clustering of the RDKIT-generated conformations. We hope our findings can help the community to revise the deep learning methods for MCG. The code of the proposed algorithm could be found at https://gist.github.com/ZhouGengmo/5b565f51adafcd911c0bc115b2ef027c.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。