arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2302.03469cs.SE
收藏

公民科技软件开发中的矛盾动机:一个草根项目的分析

Contradicting Motivations in Civic Tech Software Development: Analysis of a Grassroots Project

Antti Knutas, Dominik Siemon, Natasha Tylosky, Giovanni Maccani

AI总结:

本文以扩展活动理论分析草根公民科技项目,发现参与者在大局动机上一致,矛盾主要源于实施细节、规划及设计技术方案的收敛,揭示了将开发过程视为演化活动系统的价值。

摘要:

草根公民科技,即用于社会变革的软件,是一种新兴实践,人们创建并使用软件以在社区中产生积极改变。在这项解释性案例研究中,我们运用恩格斯托姆的扩展活动理论作为理论视角,分析动机、动机与例如团体目标或开发工具支持的过程之间的关系,以及出现的矛盾。参与者在大局动机上达成一致,例如学习新技能或改善社区。主要矛盾出现在活动系统内部关于实施细节或系统动机之间,而非大局动机。两个最显著的矛盾涉及规划,以及在设计和技术方案上的收敛。这些发现证明了将公民科技开发过程作为不断演化的活动系统来考察的价值。

英文摘要:

Grassroots civic tech, or software for social change, is an emerging practice where people create and then use software to create positive change in their community. In this interpretive case study, we apply Engeström's expanded activity theory as a theoretical lens to analyze motivations, how they relate to for example group goals or development tool supported processes, and what contradictions emerge. Participants agreed on big picture motivations, such as learning new skills or improving the community. The main contradictions occurred inside activity systems on details of implementation or between system motives, instead of big picture motivations. Two most significant contradictions involved planning, and converging on design and technical approaches. These findings demonstrate the value of examining civic tech development processes as evolving activity systems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑