软件工程参与研究中的多样性意识
Diversity Awareness in Software Engineering Participant Research
摘要:
多样性和包容性是塑造有益于整个社会的技术创新的必要先决条件。多样性考虑的一个常见指标是软件工程(SE)研究人员、开发人员和学生中不同社会群体的代表性。然而,这并不一定意味着多样性被认为是在SE研究本身。在我们的研究中,我们探讨了多样性是如何嵌入在SE研究,特别是涉及参与者研究的研究。为此,我们选择了79篇研究论文,其中包含105项跨越三年ICSE技术轨道的参与者研究。使用内容分析方法,我们确定了SE研究人员如何报告其研究参与者的各种多样性类别,并调查:1)参与者被描述的程度,2)通常报告的多样性类别,以及3)功能多样性在SE研究中的作用。我们确定了12个不同的多样性类别报告在SE参与者的研究。我们的研究结果表明,即使大多数SE研究报告的参与者的多样性,SE研究往往强调专业的多样性数据,如职业和工作经验,社会多样性数据,如性别或参与者的位置。此外,我们的研究结果表明,参与者的多样性很少被分析或反映后,当SE研究人员讨论他们的研究结果,结果或限制。为了帮助研究人员自我评估他们的研究多样性意识,我们提出了一个多样性意识模型和准则,SE研究人员可以应用到他们的研究。通过这项研究,我们希望阐明一种新的方法来解决SE领域的多样性和包容性危机。
英文摘要:
Diversity and inclusion are necessary prerequisites for shaping technological innovation that benefits society as a whole. A common indicator of diversity consideration is the representation of different social groups among software engineering (SE) researchers, developers, and students. However, this does not necessarily entail that diversity is considered in the SE research itself. In our study, we examine how diversity is embedded in SE research, particularly research that involves participant studies. To this end, we have selected 79 research papers containing 105 participant studies spanning three years of ICSE technical tracks. Using a content analytical approach, we identified how SE researchers report the various diversity categories of their study participants and investigated: 1) the extent to which participants are described, 2) what diversity categories are commonly reported, and 3) the function diversity serves in the SE studies. We identified 12 different diversity categories reported in SE participant studies. Our results demonstrate that even though most SE studies report on the diversity of participants, SE research often emphasizes professional diversity data, such as occupation and work experience, over social diversity data, such as gender or location of the participants. Furthermore, our results show that participant diversity is seldom analyzed or reflected upon when SE researchers discuss their study results, outcome or limitations. To help researchers self-assess their study diversity awareness, we propose a diversity awareness model and guidelines that SE researchers can apply to their research. With this study, we hope to shed light on a new approach to tackling the diversity and inclusion crisis in the SE field.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。