arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2301.13329cs.LOcs.CC
收藏

多结构博弈及其扩展

Multi-Structural Games and Beyond

Marco Carmosino, Ronald Fagin, Neil Immerman, Phokion Kolaitis, Jonathan Lenchner, Rik Sengupta

AI总结:

本文分析多结构博弈与EF博弈的差异,提出量词-变量树博弈及句法博弈族,以同时刻画一阶逻辑的量词数、变量数等句法度量。

摘要:

多结构(MS)博弈是刻画一阶句子量词数量的组合博弈。从定义表面看,MS博弈与Ehrenfeucht-Fraïssé(EF)博弈有两点不同:首先,MS博弈在两组结构上进行,而EF博弈在一对结构上进行;其次,在MS博弈中,Duplicator可以对结构进行任意数量的复制。在本文第一部分,我们对MS博弈进行了更细致的分析,并将其与EF博弈作更紧密的比较。特别地,我们指出使用结构集合是本质所在;当MS博弈在结构对上进行时,它们刻画的是具有固定量词数量的一阶句子的布尔组合。此后,我们关注MS博弈与EF博弈之间的另一个重要差异,即Spoiler为赢得某些MS博弈而必须在前一步落子之上继续落子。通过分析MS博弈中实现的类型,我们界定了Spoiler从不在前一步落子之上继续落子的MS博弈变体的表达能力。在第二部分,我们关注同时刻画一阶逻辑中的量词数量和变量数量。我们表明MS博弈的自然变体并不能实现这一点。随后,我们引入一种新博弈,即量词-变量树博弈,并证明它能够同时刻画量词数量和变量数量。最后,我们将该博弈推广为一族博弈,即句法博弈,它们能够同时刻画合理的句法度量和变量数量。

英文摘要:

Multi-structural (MS) games are combinatorial games that capture the number of quantifiers of first-order sentences. On the face of their definition, MS games differ from Ehrenfeucht-Fraisse (EF) games in two ways: first, MS games are played on two sets of structures, while EF games are played on a pair of structures; second, in MS games, Duplicator can make any number of copies of structures. In the first part of this paper, we perform a finer analysis of MS games and develop a closer comparison of MS games with EF games. In particular, we point out that the use of sets of structures is of the essence and that when MS games are played on pairs of structures, they capture Boolean combinations of first-order sentences with a fixed number of quantifiers. After this, we focus on another important difference between MS games and EF games, namely, the necessity for Spoiler to play on top of a previous move in order to win some MS games. Via an analysis of the types realized during MS games, we delineate the expressive power of the variant of MS games in which Spoiler never plays on top of a previous move. In the second part we focus on simultaneously capturing number of quantifiers and number of variables in first-order logic. We show that natural variants of the MS game do *not* achieve this. We then introduce a new game, the quantifier-variable tree game, and show that it simultaneously captures the number of quantifiers and number of variables. We conclude by generalizing this game to a family of games, the *syntactic games*, that simultaneously capture reasonable syntactic measures and the number of variables.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑