When gravity is sourced by a quantum system, there is tension between its role as the mediator of a fundamental interaction, which is expected to acquire nonclassical features, and its role in determining the properties of spacetime, which is inherently classical. Fundamentally, this tension should result in breaking one of the fundamental principles of quantum theory or general relativity, but it is usually hard to assess which one without resorting to a specific model. Here, we answer this question in a theory-independent way using General Probabilistic Theories (GPTs). We consider the interactions of the gravitational field with a single matter system, and derive a no-go theorem showing that when gravity is classical at least one of the following assumptions needs to be violated: (i) Matter degrees of freedom are described by fully non-classical degrees of freedom; (ii) Interactions between matter degrees of freedom and the gravitational field are reversible; (iii) Matter degrees of freedom back-react on the gravitational field. We argue that this implies that theories of classical gravity and quantum matter must be fundamentally irreversible, as is the case in the recent model of Oppenheim et al. Conversely if we require that the interaction between quantum matter and the gravitational field is reversible, then the gravitational field must be non-classical.
Collapse-based models for gravity do not violate the entanglement-based witness of non-classicality
QICI Quantum Information and Computation Initiative, School of Computing and Data Science, The University of Hong Kong(香港大学计算与数据科学学院量子信息与计算倡议);Clarendon Laboratory, University of Oxford(牛津大学克拉伦登实验室)
Some Reflections on the Status of Conventional Quantum Theory when Applied to Quantum Gravity
目前所有的量子引力方法基本上都采用标准的量子理论,特别是包括连续统量,如实数或复数。然而,我想指出,这可能是根本错误的,因为在标准量子理论中使用这些连续统量可以追溯到关于空间和时间性质的某些{ \em a priori}假设:这些假设可能与量子引力理论所采用的空间和时间观点不相容。我的猜想是,在某种尚未确定的意义上,每一种时空都有一种相应的量子理论,在这种量子理论中,连续统量不一定出现,而是被适合于特定时空的结构所取代。于是,Topos理论作为一种可能的工具出现了,它把与不同时空有关的这些不同理论“粘合”在一起。作为一个具体的例子,使用拓扑思想,我总结了最近的工作应用预层理论的科赫-Specher定理和分配值的物理量在量子理论。
Probing the Quantum Nature of Gravity through Classical Diffusion
University of Trieste(的里雅斯特大学);INFN, Sezione di Trieste(意大利国家核物理研究所的里雅斯特分部);Queen’s University, Belfast(贝尔法斯特女王大学);Okinawa Institute of Science and Technology Graduate University(冲绳科学技术大学院大学);Istituto di Fotonica e Nanotecnologie IFN–CNR(意大利国家研究委员会光子和纳米技术研究所)