受托责任:促进自动决策中的公众信任
Fiduciary Responsibility: Facilitating Public Trust in Automated Decision Making
摘要:
自动化决策系统正在越来越多地部署,并以多种积极和消极的方式影响公众。政府和私人机构使用这些系统根据某些人为设计的规则处理信息,以解决社会问题或组织挑战。研究和现实世界的经验都表明,公众对自动决策系统和部署它们的机构缺乏信任。软弱理论认为,如果管理自动化决策系统的机构履行其受托责任,公众更有可能信任和支持自动化决策系统做出的决策或受其影响。然而,公众往往从来不了解这些制度如何运作,也不了解由此产生的体制决定是如何作出的。自动决策系统的"黑箱“效应降低了公众对正直和可信度的看法。其结果是,公众失去了识别、质疑和纠正不公平或与公共产品或利益损失相关的成本的能力。本立场文件界定并解释了信托责任在自动化决策系统中的作用。我们将自动化决策系统定义为数据科学生命周期(DSL),并在DSL的背景下研究受托责任的影响。领域特定语言中的受托责任提供了一种方法,可以解决公众对自动决策系统和使用它们做出影响公众的决策的机构缺乏信任的问题。我们认为,信托责任体现在DSL的几个方面,每一个都需要自己的不信任来源的缓解。为了实例化受托责任,洛杉矶警察局(LAPD)预测警务案例研究。
英文摘要:
Automated decision-making systems are being increasingly deployed and affect the public in a multitude of positive and negative ways. Governmental and private institutions use these systems to process information according to certain human-devised rules in order to address social problems or organizational challenges. Both research and real-world experience indicate that the public lacks trust in automated decision-making systems and the institutions that deploy them. The recreancy theorem argues that the public is more likely to trust and support decisions made or influenced by automated decision-making systems if the institutions that administer them meet their fiduciary responsibility. However, often the public is never informed of how these systems operate and resultant institutional decisions are made. A ``black box'' effect of automated decision-making systems reduces the public's perceptions of integrity and trustworthiness. The result is that the public loses the capacity to identify, challenge, and rectify unfairness or the costs associated with the loss of public goods or benefits. The current position paper defines and explains the role of fiduciary responsibility within an automated decision-making system. We formulate an automated decision-making system as a data science lifecycle (DSL) and examine the implications of fiduciary responsibility within the context of the DSL. Fiduciary responsibility within DSLs provides a methodology for addressing the public's lack of trust in automated decision-making systems and the institutions that employ them to make decisions affecting the public. We posit that fiduciary responsibility manifests in several contexts of a DSL, each of which requires its own mitigation of sources of mistrust. To instantiate fiduciary responsibility, a Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) predictive policing case study is examined.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。