We study causal inference in randomized experiments (or quasi-experiments) following a $2\times 2$ factorial design. There are two treatments, denoted $A$ and $B$, and units are randomly assigned to one of four categories: treatment $A$ alone, treatment $B$ alone, joint treatment, or none. Allowing for endogenous non-compliance with the two binary instruments representing the intended assignment, as well as unrestricted interference across the two treatments, we derive the causal interpretation of various instrumental variable estimands under more general compliance conditions than in the literature. In general, if treatment takeup is driven by both instruments for some units, it becomes difficult to separate treatment interaction from treatment effect heterogeneity. We provide auxiliary conditions and various bounding strategies that may help zero in on causally interesting parameters. As an empirical illustration, we apply our results to a program randomly offering two different treatments, namely tutoring and financial incentives, to first year college students, in order to assess the treatments' effects on academic performance.
Endogenous Treatment Effect Estimation with some Invalid and Irrelevant Instruments
工具变量(IV)回归是估计内源性处理效应的常用方法。传统的IV方法要求所有的工具都是相关的和有效的。然而,这是不切实际的,特别是在高维模型中,当我们考虑一个大的候选IV集。在本文中,我们提出了一个IV估计存在的无效和不相关的工具(称为R2 IVE)的内源性处理效应的估计。本文通过考虑一个真正的高维IV模型和一个非参数简化形式方程,扩展了Kang等人(2016)的范围。结果表明,我们的程序可以选择相关的和有效的仪器一致,建议的R2 IVE是root-n一致的和渐近正态的。蒙特卡罗模拟表明,与现有的高维IV估计量(例如NAIVE(Fan和Zhong,2018)和sisVIVE(Kang等人,(2016年)),如果存在无效工具。在实证研究中,我们重新审视了贸易与增长的经典问题(Frankel and Romer,1999)。
Nonparametric Bounds on Treatment Effects with Imperfect Instruments
本文将Nevo和Rosen(2012)的辨识结果推广到非参数模型。我们推导出非参数界的平均处理效应时,一个不完美的工具。与Nevo and Rosen(2012)一样,我们假设不完美工具与未观测潜变量之间的相关性与内生变量与潜变量之间的相关性具有相同的符号。我们证明了Manski和Pepper(2000,2009)引入的单调处理选择和单调工具变量限制共同隐含了这一假设。此外,我们还展示了单调治疗反应假设如何有助于收紧界限。所识别的集合可以写成交界的形式,这样更有利于推理。我们说明了我们的方法,使用全国青年男子纵向调查的数据,以估计回报上学。
Double Machine Learning for Static Panel Data with Instrumental Variables: New Method and Applications
Erasmus School of Economics, Erasmus University(伊拉斯谟斯大学经济研究生院);Tinbergen Institute(丁伯根研究所);Department of Business Analytics and Applied Economics, Queen Mary University of London(伦敦大学玛丽女王学院商业分析与应用经济学系);Institute for Social and Economic Research, University of Essex(埃塞克斯大学社会与经济研究所)
本文提出静态面板模型中处理内生处理的双重机器学习估计器(panel IV DML),并引入弱识别诊断,通过三个迁移研究验证其在高维非线性影响下的稳健性与准确性。