DBpedia和Wikidata中的政治代表偏见是下游处理的挑战
Political representation bias in DBpedia and Wikidata as a challenge for downstream processing
摘要:
Diversity Searcher是一个最初开发的工具,用于帮助分析新闻媒体文本中的多样性。它依赖于某种形式的自动内容分析,因此依赖于先前的假设,并取决于与多样性和公平性有关的某些设计选择。一个这样的设计选择是所使用的外部知识源。在本文中,我们讨论了这些来源对内容分析结果的影响。我们比较了两个数据源,多样性搜索与- DBpedia和维基数据-就其本体论的覆盖面和多样性,并描述了所产生的文本语料库分析的影响。我们描述了1990年至2020年期间比利时政党在英语DBpedia,荷兰语DBpedia和Wikidata中的相对过度或不足代表性的案例研究,并强调了该数据分析设计所需的许多决定及其背后的假设,以及结果的影响。特别是,我们在英语DBpedia中发现了政治权利的惊人过度代表性。
英文摘要:
Diversity Searcher is a tool originally developed to help analyse diversity in news media texts. It relies on a form of automated content analysis and thus rests on prior assumptions and depends on certain design choices related to diversity and fairness. One such design choice is the external knowledge source(s) used. In this article, we discuss implications that these sources can have on the results of content analysis. We compare two data sources that Diversity Searcher has worked with - DBpedia and Wikidata - with respect to their ontological coverage and diversity, and describe implications for the resulting analyses of text corpora. We describe a case study of the relative over- or under-representation of Belgian political parties between 1990 and 2020 in the English-language DBpedia, the Dutch-language DBpedia, and Wikidata, and highlight the many decisions needed with regard to the design of this data analysis and the assumptions behind it, as well as implications from the results. In particular, we came across a staggering over-representation of the political right in the English-language DBpedia.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。