arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2212.14622econ.EM
收藏

识别具有主观有序结果变量的因果效应

Identifying causal effects with subjective ordinal outcomes

Leonard Goff

AI总结:

本文研究将主观有序量表响应作为因果推断结果变量的问题,证明了在特定独立性条件下非参数回归可恢复平均因果效应,并应用于收入比较对主观幸福感的影响分析。

摘要:

调查问题通常要求受访者从有序量表中进行选择,其中类别的含义是主观的,允许每个人在回答时应用自己的定义。本文研究在因果推断中将这些响应作为结果变量的使用,考虑了个体间对类别解释的异质性。我发现,当连续处理变量与以下两者在统计上独立时:i) 潜在结果;ii) 报告风格的异质性,对响应类别编号关于该处理变量的非参数回归能够恢复一个量,该量与处于相邻响应类别边界个体间的平均因果效应成正比。给定回归系数的量级本身没有意义,但关于两个此类处理变量的局部回归导数之比,识别了它们效应凸平均的相对量级。这些结果可视为二元处理变量类似结果的极限情形,尽管在极限之外涉及离散处理的量级比较不易解释。在进一步假设下,我获得了涉及离散处理比较的部分识别结果。实证应用通过重新考察收入比较对主观幸福感的影响来说明这些结果,且不假设响应的基数性或人际可比性。

英文摘要:

Survey questions often ask respondents to select from ordered scales where the meanings of the categories are subjective, leaving each individual free to apply their own definitions in answering. This paper studies the use of these responses as an outcome variable in causal inference, accounting for variation in interpretation of the categories across individuals. I find that when a continuous treatment variable is statistically independent of both i) potential outcomes; and ii) heterogeneity in reporting styles, a nonparametric regression of response category number on that treatment variable recovers a quantity proportional to an average causal effect among individuals who are on the margin between successive response categories. The magnitude of a given regression coefficient is not meaningful on its own, but the ratio of local regression derivatives with respect to two such treatment variables identifies the relative magnitudes of convex averages of their effects. These results can be seen as limiting cases of analogous results for binary treatment variables, though comparisons of magnitude involving discrete treatments are not as readily interpretable outside of the limit. I obtain a partial identification result for comparisons involving discrete treatments under further assumptions. An empirical application illustrates the results by revisiting the effects of income comparisons on subjective well-being, without assuming cardinality or interpersonal comparability of responses.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑