谨慎的线程:积极主动地帮助用户评估和缓解在线讨论中的紧张局势
Thread With Caution: Proactively Helping Users Assess and Deescalate Tension in Their Online Discussions
摘要:
不文明仍然是在线讨论平台的一个主要挑战,以至于即使是善意的用户之间的对话也经常会变成不文明的行为。传统上,平台依赖于版主(无论是否有算法帮助)采取纠正措施,如删除评论或禁止用户。在这项工作中,我们提出了一个补充的范例,直接授权用户主动提高他们对现有的紧张局势的认识,他们正在参与的对话,并积极引导他们,因为他们正在起草他们的答复,以避免进一步升级。作为这种模式的概念证明,我们设计了一种算法工具,直接向用户提供这种主动信息,并在一个流行的讨论平台上进行用户研究。通过混合方法的方法相结合的调查与随机对照实验,我们发现定性和定量的见解,参与者如何利用和反应这些信息。大多数与会者报告说,他们认为这一积极主动的范例很有价值,指出这有助于他们发现否则可能会遗漏的紧张关系,并促使他们进一步思考自己的答复并加以修改。当我们的工具警告参与者,他们的对话有可能偏离轨道,变成不文明的行为时,与在工具被禁用的控制条件下,参与者如何起草回复的比较证实了这些影响。这些初步研究结果突出了这种以用户为中心的范例的潜力,并指出了未来实施的具体方向。
英文摘要:
Incivility remains a major challenge for online discussion platforms, to such an extent that even conversations between well-intentioned users can often derail into uncivil behavior. Traditionally, platforms have relied on moderators to -- with or without algorithmic assistance -- take corrective actions such as removing comments or banning users. In this work we propose a complementary paradigm that directly empowers users by proactively enhancing their awareness about existing tension in the conversation they are engaging in and actively guides them as they are drafting their replies to avoid further escalation. As a proof of concept for this paradigm, we design an algorithmic tool that provides such proactive information directly to users, and conduct a user study in a popular discussion platform. Through a mixed methods approach combining surveys with a randomized controlled experiment, we uncover qualitative and quantitative insights regarding how the participants utilize and react to this information. Most participants report finding this proactive paradigm valuable, noting that it helps them to identify tension that they may have otherwise missed and prompts them to further reflect on their own replies and to revise them. These effects are corroborated by a comparison of how the participants draft their reply when our tool warns them that their conversation is at risk of derailing into uncivil behavior versus in a control condition where the tool is disabled. These preliminary findings highlight the potential of this user-centered paradigm and point to concrete directions for future implementations.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。