谎言可以被伪造吗?从机器学习视角比较低风险与高风险欺骗视频数据集
Can lies be faked? Comparing low-stakes and high-stakes deception video datasets from a Machine Learning perspective
AI总结:
针对低风险与高风险欺骗数据能否通用的问题,本文用仅基于视频的深度学习分类器比较两类DD数据集,发现低风险训练数据更利于识别高风险欺骗,但作为增强数据反而降低性能。
摘要:
尽管谎言在人类社会中具有重大影响,且人类在欺骗检测(DD)中的准确率仅为54%,但由于数据稀缺,执行自动化DD的机器学习系统仍无法在现实环境中得到恰当应用。公开可用的DD数据集很少,而新数据集的创建受到低风险谎言与高风险谎言之间概念性区别的阻碍。从理论上讲,这两种谎言差异极大,以至于一种谎言的数据集不能用于另一种谎言的应用。尽管获取低风险欺骗数据更容易,因为它可以在受控环境中被模拟(伪造),但这些谎言不具备真实高风险谎言那样的意义或深度;高风险谎言更难获得,并且是自动化DD系统的实际兴趣所在。为了从实践角度研究这种区别是否成立,我们设计了若干实验,比较一个高风险DD数据集和一个低风险DD数据集,在仅使用视频数据的深度学习分类器上评估它们的结果。在我们的实验中,使用低风险谎言训练的网络在分类高风险欺骗时的准确率高于分类低风险欺骗,尽管将低风险谎言作为高风险数据集的增强策略会降低其准确率。
英文摘要:
Despite the great impact of lies in human societies and a meager 54% human accuracy for Deception Detection (DD), Machine Learning systems that perform automated DD are still not viable for proper application in real-life settings due to data scarcity. Few publicly available DD datasets exist and the creation of new datasets is hindered by the conceptual distinction between low-stakes and high-stakes lies. Theoretically, the two kinds of lies are so distinct that a dataset of one kind could not be used for applications for the other kind. Even though it is easier to acquire data on low-stakes deception since it can be simulated (faked) in controlled settings, these lies do not hold the same significance or depth as genuine high-stakes lies, which are much harder to obtain and hold the practical interest of automated DD systems. To investigate whether this distinction holds true from a practical perspective, we design several experiments comparing a high-stakes DD dataset and a low-stakes DD dataset evaluating their results on a Deep Learning classifier working exclusively from video data. In our experiments, a network trained in low-stakes lies had better accuracy classifying high-stakes deception than low-stakes, although using low-stakes lies as an augmentation strategy for the high-stakes dataset decreased its accuracy.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。