arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2211.01240q-fin.PM
收藏

关于均值方差准则与随机优势准则的等价性

On The Equivalence Of The Mean Variance Criterion And Stochastic Dominance Criteria

George Samartzis, Nikitas Pittis

摘要:

研究了两种彩票的均值方差准则(MVC)与最大期望效用准则(MEUC)等价的充要条件。基于Chamberlain(1983),我们得出了在任何对称椭圆分布下MVC等价于二阶随机优势规则(SSDR)的结论。然后我们讨论Schuhmacher et al.(2021)的工作。虽然他们的理论研究结果推断,平均方差分析仍然有效的偏椭圆分布下,我们认为,这并不意味着MVC与SSDR相一致。事实上,生成遵循偏正态分布的多个MV对,很明显,对于某些类型的风险厌恶投资者来说,MVC未能与SSDR相一致。在本文的第二部分中,我们考察了Levy和Markowitz(1979)的前提,即“在任何近似二次效用函数下,MVC推导出投资者期望效用的最大化,而不对彩票的分布做任何进一步的假设”。利用蒙特卡罗模拟,我们发现近似二次效用函数的集合太窄。具体来说,我们的模拟表明,$\log{(a+Z)}$和$(1+Z)^a$几乎是二次的,而$-e^{-a(1+Z)}$和$-(1+Z)^{-a}$无法近似二次效用函数下的极值或稳定帕累托分布。

英文摘要:

We study the necessary and sufficient conditions under which the Mean-Variance Criterion (MVC) is equivalent to the Maximum Expected Utility Criterion (MEUC), for two lotteries. Based on Chamberlain (1983), we conclude that the MVC is equivalent to the Second-order Stochastic Dominance Rule (SSDR) under any symmetric Elliptical distribution. We then discuss the work of Schuhmacher et al. (2021). Although their theoretical findings deduce that the Mean-Variance Analysis remains valid under Skew-Elliptical distributions, we argue that this does not entail that the MVC coincides with the SSDR. In fact, generating multiple MV-pairs that follow a Skew-Normal distribution it becomes evident that the MVC fails to coincide with the SSDR for some types of risk-averse investors. In the second part of this work, we examine the premise of Levy and Markowitz (1979) that "the MVC deduces the maximization of the expected utility of an investor, under any approximately quadratic utility function, without making any further assumption on the distribution of the lotteries". Using Monte Carlo Simulations, we find out that the set of approximately quadratic utility functions is too narrow. Specifically, our simulations indicate that $\log{(a+Z)}$ and $(1+Z)^a$ are almost quadratic, while $-e^{-a(1+Z)}$ and $-(1+Z)^{-a}$ fail to approximate a quadratic utility function under either an Extreme Value or a Stable Pareto distribution.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑