回溯反事实
Backtracking Counterfactuals
AI总结:
本文在结构因果模型框架内首次形式化并算法化了回溯反事实推理,将反事实差异归因于初始条件改变而非因果规律干预,并关联可解释人工智能研究。
摘要:
反事实推理——设想在某些情况与(事实上)实际发生的情况不同(反事实)的假设场景或可能世界——在人类认知中无处不在。传统上,反事实改变的情况被视为“小奇迹”,它们在局部违反自然规律的同时共享相同的初始条件。在Pearl的结构因果模型(SCM)框架中,这一点通过干预得到了数学上的严格化,即修改因果规律而共享外生变量的取值。然而,近年来,这种纯粹干预主义的反事实解释日益受到哲学家和心理学家的审视。相反,他们提出了一种回溯式的反事实解释,根据这种解释,在反事实世界中因果规律保持不变;与事实世界的差异被“回溯”到改变的初始条件(外生变量)。在本文中,我们在SCM框架内探索并形式化了这种替代性的反事实推理模式。尽管有充分证据表明人类会进行回溯推理,但据我们所知,本文构成了回溯反事实的第一个一般性阐述和算法化。我们在相关文献的背景下讨论了我们的回溯语义,并与可解释人工智能(XAI)的最新发展建立了联系。
英文摘要:
Counterfactual reasoning -- envisioning hypothetical scenarios, or possible worlds, where some circumstances are different from what (f)actually occurred (counter-to-fact) -- is ubiquitous in human cognition. Conventionally, counterfactually-altered circumstances have been treated as "small miracles" that locally violate the laws of nature while sharing the same initial conditions. In Pearl's structural causal model (SCM) framework this is made mathematically rigorous via interventions that modify the causal laws while the values of exogenous variables are shared. In recent years, however, this purely interventionist account of counterfactuals has increasingly come under scrutiny from both philosophers and psychologists. Instead, they suggest a backtracking account of counterfactuals, according to which the causal laws remain unchanged in the counterfactual world; differences to the factual world are instead "backtracked" to altered initial conditions (exogenous variables). In the present work, we explore and formalise this alternative mode of counterfactual reasoning within the SCM framework. Despite ample evidence that humans backtrack, the present work constitutes, to the best of our knowledge, the first general account and algorithmisation of backtracking counterfactuals. We discuss our backtracking semantics in the context of related literature and draw connections to recent developments in explainable artificial intelligence (XAI).
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。