arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2210.10568cs.CY
收藏

在机器学习和基于卫星图像的贫困预测这一新领域,什么才是重要的?与潜在下游应用和开发研究相关的综述

What matters in the new field of machine learning and satellite imagery-based poverty predictions? A review with relevance for potential downstream applications and development research

Olan Hall, Francis Dompae, Ibrahim Wahab, Fred Mawunyo Dzanku

摘要:

本文回顾了基于卫星和机器学习的贫困估计的最新技术水平,并发现了一些有趣的结果。在回顾的研究中,与福利预测能力相关的最重要因素是所采用的预处理步骤的数量,所使用的数据集的数量,目标福利指标的类型以及人工智能模型的选择。正如预期的那样,使用硬指标作为目标的研究在预测福利方面比那些针对软指标的研究取得了更好的成绩。还预计的预处理步骤和数据集的数量与福利估计性能具有积极的和统计上显着的关系。更重要的是,我们发现ML和DL的组合与单独使用任何一种相比,预测能力显著提高了15个百分点。令人惊讶的是,我们发现,所使用的卫星图像的空间分辨率是重要的,但不是至关重要的性能的关系是积极的,但不具有统计意义。没有证据表明统计学显著性效应的预测性能随时间推移而发生,这一发现也是出乎意料的。这些发现对该领域的未来研究具有重要意义。例如,鉴于中等分辨率的SI似乎可以实现类似的结果,因此必须重新考虑用于获取更昂贵、更高分辨率的SI的努力和资源水平。越来越流行的ML、DL和TL结合的方法,无论是以并发还是迭代的方式,都可能成为实现更好结果的标准方法。

英文摘要:

This paper reviews the state of the art in satellite and machine learning based poverty estimates and finds some interesting results. The most important factors correlated to the predictive power of welfare in the reviewed studies are the number of pre-processing steps employed, the number of datasets used, the type of welfare indicator targeted, and the choice of AI model. As expected, studies that used hard indicators as targets achieved better performance in predicting welfare than those that targeted soft ones. Also expected was the number of pre-processing steps and datasets used having a positive and statistically significant relationship with welfare estimation performance. Even more important, we find that the combination of ML and DL significantly increases predictive power by as much as 15 percentage points compared to using either alone. Surprisingly, we find that the spatial resolution of the satellite imagery used is important but not critical to the performance as the relationship is positive but not statistically significant. The finding of no evidence indicating that predictive performance of a statistically significant effect occurs over time was also unexpected. These findings have important implications for future research in this domain. For example, the level of effort and resources devoted to acquiring more expensive, higher resolution SI will have to be reconsidered given that medium resolutions ones seem to achieve similar results. The increasingly popular approach of combining ML, DL, and TL, either in a concurrent or iterative manner, might become a standard approach to achieving better results.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑