用平台碎片做数据科学:对YouTube上虚假观点的调查
Doing data science with platforms crumbs: an investigation into fakes views on YouTube
摘要:
本文有助于学术访问社交媒体数据正在进行的讨论,讨论这种访问被禁止的情况下,尽管它的价值理解和打击网上虚假信息,尽管没有隐私或版权问题。我们的研究关注YouTube的参与度指标,更具体地说,是该平台删除“虚假视图”的方式(即,被平台视为人为或非法的观点)。我们使用从1000个法国YouTube频道中提取的一年半的数据,展示了这种现象的巨大程度,这涉及我们语料库中的绝大多数频道和一半以上的视频。我们的分析表明,大多数假新闻在视频的生命周期中相对较晚才被纠正,并且视频的最终观看次数与他们收到的假观看次数并不独立。我们讨论了延迟更正可能在内容传播中产生的潜在危害:通过夸大观看次数,非法观看可能会使视频看起来比实际更受欢迎,并毫无疑问地鼓励其人工和算法推荐。不幸的是,我们无法对这种现象提供明确的评估,因为YouTube在其API或界面中没有提供关于虚假视图的信息。因此,这份文件也呼吁YouTube和其他在线平台提高对在线公共辩论质量具有关键影响的信息的透明度。
英文摘要:
This paper contributes to the ongoing discussions on the scholarly access to social media data, discussing a case where this access is barred despite its value for understanding and countering online disinformation and despite the absence of privacy or copyright issues. Our study concerns YouTube's engagement metrics and, more specifically, the way in which the platform removes "fake views" (i.e., views considered as artificial or illegitimate by the platform). Working with one and a half year of data extracted from a thousand French YouTube channels, we show the massive extent of this phenomenon, which concerns the large majority of the channels and more than half the videos in our corpus. Our analysis indicates that most fakes news are corrected relatively late in the life of the videos and that the final view counts of the videos are not independent from the fake views they received. We discuss the potential harm that delays in corrections could produce in content diffusion: by inflating views counts, illegitimate views could make a video appear more popular than it is and unwarrantedly encourage its human and algorithmic recommendation. Unfortunately, we cannot offer a definitive assessment of this phenomenon, because YouTube provides no information on fake views in its API or interface. This paper is, therefore, also a call for greater transparency by YouTube and other online platforms about information that can have crucial implications for the quality of online public debate.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。