arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2209.14655cs.DL
收藏

支持数据发现:支持专家和研究人员观点的综合比较

Supporting data discovery: A meta-synthesis comparing perspectives of support specialists and researchers

Guangyuan Sun, Tanja Friedrich, Kathleen Gregory, Brigitte Mathiak

摘要:

目的:数据发现实践目前倾向于从研究人员或支持专家的角度进行研究。这种分离是有问题的,因为支持专家很容易根据对研究人员实践的看法而不是实践本身来构建基础设施和服务。本文汇集并分析了这两种观点,以支持建立有效的基础设施和服务的数据发现。研究方法:这是作者在过去六年中进行的工作的综合合成,调查了来自不同学科的研究人员的数据发现实践,重点是社会科学和支持专家。我们汇集并重新分析了从德国社会科学领域的6名支持专家,新加坡的21名社会科学家,来自多个学科的10名研究人员和3名支持专家的深入访谈研究中收集的数据,以及来自多个学科的1630名研究人员和47名支持专家的全球调查,一项由来自社会科学领域的12名研究人员参与的观察性研究,以及对来自多个学科的25名支持专家进行的用例分析。结果如下:我们发现,在社会科学和其他学科中,研究人员和支持专家对数据发现的需求和想法有许多相似之处。然而,我们已经确定了一些差异,最值得注意的是数据发现与网络搜索,文献搜索和社交网络的互连。结论:最后,我们提出了不同类型的支持工作如何解决这些差异点,以更好地支持研究人员的数据发现实践的建议。

英文摘要:

Purpose: Data discovery practices currently tend to be studied from the perspective of researchers or the perspective of support specialists. This separation is problematic, as it becomes easy for support specialists to build infrastructures and services based on perceptions of researchers' practices, rather than the practices themselves. This paper brings together and analyzes both perspectives to support the building of effective infrastructures and services for data discovery. Methods: This is a meta-synthesis of work the authors have conducted over the last six years investigating the data discovery practices of researchers from different disciplines, with a focus on the social sciences, and support specialists. We bring together and re-analyze data collected from in-depth interview studies with 6 support specialists in the field of social science in Germany, with 21 social scientists in Singapore, an interview with 10 researchers and 3 support specialists from multiple disciplines, a global survey with 1630 researchers and 47 support specialists from multiple disciplines, an observational study with 12 researchers from the field of social science and a use case analysis of 25 support specialists from multiple disciplines. Results: We found that there are many similarities in what researchers and support specialists want and think about data discovery, both in social sciences and in other disciplines. There are, however, some differences which we have identified, most notably the interconnection of data discovery with web search, literature search and social networks. Conclusion: We conclude by proposing recommendations for how different types of support work can address these points of difference to better support researchers' data discovery practices.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑