法律指导代码:一种将人工智能与人类对齐的法律信息学方法
Law Informs Code: A Legal Informatics Approach to Aligning Artificial Intelligence with Humans
AI总结:
本文提出“法律指导代码”研究议程,通过将法律知识和推理嵌入AI,利用法律过程生成的数据促进模糊人类目标的稳健规范,从而增强人机对齐与社会AI对齐。
摘要:
我们目前无法以可靠地引导AI行为的方式来明确人类目标和社会价值观。立法和法律解释构成了一个计算引擎,将不透明的人类价值观转化为清晰的指令。“法律指导代码”是将法律知识和推理嵌入AI的研究议程。类似于法律合同各方无法预见其未来关系的每一个潜在意外情况,立法者也无法预测其提案法案将被应用的所有情况,我们无法事前指定能证明可引导良好AI行为的规则。法律理论和实践已经开发出一系列工具来解决这些规范问题。例如,法律标准允许人类发展共同理解并将其适应于新情况。与法律更寻常的用途(例如,通过制裁威胁来威慑不良行为)相反,法律被用作人类如何传达其目标以及社会重视什么的表达,这就是法律指导代码。我们描述了由法律过程(立法方法、成文法解释、合同起草、法律标准的应用、法律推理等)生成的数据如何促进本质上模糊的人类目标的稳健规范。这增加了人机对齐和AI的局部有用性。为了实现社会与AI的对齐,我们提出了一个将法律理解为多智能体对齐应用哲学的框架。尽管法律部分反映了历史偶然的政治权力——因此并非公民偏好的完美聚合——但如果被正确解析,其提炼提供了可用的关于社会价值观的最合法的计算理解。如果法律最终指导强大的AI,参与审议性政治过程以改进法律将具有更大的意义。
英文摘要:
We are currently unable to specify human goals and societal values in a way that reliably directs AI behavior. Law-making and legal interpretation form a computational engine that converts opaque human values into legible directives. "Law Informs Code" is the research agenda embedding legal knowledge and reasoning in AI. Similar to how parties to a legal contract cannot foresee every potential contingency of their future relationship, and legislators cannot predict all the circumstances under which their proposed bills will be applied, we cannot ex ante specify rules that provably direct good AI behavior. Legal theory and practice have developed arrays of tools to address these specification problems. For instance, legal standards allow humans to develop shared understandings and adapt them to novel situations. In contrast to more prosaic uses of the law (e.g., as a deterrent of bad behavior through the threat of sanction), leveraged as an expression of how humans communicate their goals, and what society values, Law Informs Code. We describe how data generated by legal processes (methods of law-making, statutory interpretation, contract drafting, applications of legal standards, legal reasoning, etc.) can facilitate the robust specification of inherently vague human goals. This increases human-AI alignment and the local usefulness of AI. Toward society-AI alignment, we present a framework for understanding law as the applied philosophy of multi-agent alignment. Although law is partly a reflection of historically contingent political power - and thus not a perfect aggregation of citizen preferences - if properly parsed, its distillation offers the most legitimate computational comprehension of societal values available. If law eventually informs powerful AI, engaging in the deliberative political process to improve law takes on even more meaning.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。