反馈交流与网络亲和力--以网络同人小说作家为例
Feedback Exchange and Online Affinity: A Case Study of Online Fanfiction Writers
摘要:
反馈是创作过程中至关重要的一部分。先前的CSCW研究已经发明了基于对等和基于人群的系统,这些系统可以在大规模的在线陌生人之间交换反馈。然而,创作者在与他们从未见过的人进行在线评论交流时会遇到社会心理挑战。在这项研究中,我们退后一步,采取不同的方法来调查在线反馈,通过将我们的注意力投向在线亲和力空间中的创作者,反馈交流自然发生,作为兴趣驱动的参与性文化的一部分。我们对29位同人小说作家进行了一项访谈研究,调查他们如何在网上寻求反馈,以及他们如何识别和建立与反馈提供者的联系。我们确定了四种不同的反馈实践,并在反馈交换中揭示了社会需求。我们的研究结果表面的亲和力和信任的在线反馈交流的重要性,并说明作者如何建立与反馈提供者在公共和私人的在线空间的关系。受我们听到的关于连接和反馈的强大故事的启发,我们总结了未来反馈系统\textemdash的一系列设计考虑,即解决反馈中的一系列社会需求,帮助反馈寻求者表达兴趣和身份,支持反馈交换中的真实关系,以及为反馈建立包容性,安全的社区空间。
英文摘要:
Feedback is a critical piece of the creative process. Prior CSCW research has invented peer-based and crowd-based systems that exchange feedback between online strangers at scale. However, creators run into socio-psychological challenges when engaging in online critique exchange with people they have never met. In this study, we step back and take a different approach to investigate online feedback by casting our attention to creators in online affinity spaces, where feedback exchange happens naturally as part of the interest-driven participatory culture. We present an interview study with 29 fanfiction writers that investigated how they seek feedback online, and how they identified and built connections with feedback providers. We identify four distinct feedback practices and unpack the social needs in feedback exchange. Our findings surface the importance of affinity and trust in online feedback exchange and illustrate how writers built relationships with feedback providers in public and private online spaces. Inspired by the powerful stories we heard about connection and feedback, we conclude with a series of design considerations for future feedback systems\textemdash namely addressing a range of social needs in feedback, helping feedback seekers signal interests and identity, supporting authentic relationships in feedback exchange, and building inclusive, safe community spaces for feedback.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。