arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2209.09838cs.AI
收藏

论解决论点之间的冲突

On resolving conflicts between arguments

Maastricht University(马斯特里赫特大学)

Nico Roos

摘要:

论元系统是基于一个人可以为命题构造论元的想法;即,证明对一个命题的信念的结构化的理由。使用可废止规则,论证不需要在所有情况下都有效,因此,可以为命题及其否定构造一个论证。当论点支持相互冲突的命题时,其中一个论点必须被击败,这就提出了\emph{which (sub-)arguments can be subject to defeat}的问题。在法律论证中,元规则通过考虑冲突中每个论证的最后一条可废止规则来确定有效论证。由于使用最后一个规则来评估参数更容易,因此\emph{can a conflict be resolved by considering only the last defeasible rules of the arguments involved}?我们提出了一个新的论点系统,而不是推导出一个失败的参数之间的关系,\emph{undercutting-arguments}的失败可废止的规则构造。这个系统允许我们,(\textit{i})解决冲突(反驳参数的概括)只使用不一致的参数的最后规则,(\textit{ii})确定一组有效的(不败)参数在线性时间使用的算法的基础上JTMS,(\textit{iii})建立与默认逻辑的关系,和(\textit{iv})证明封闭属性,如\emph{cumulativity}。我们还提出了一个扩展的论点系统,使\emph{reasoning by cases}。

英文摘要:

Argument systems are based on the idea that one can construct arguments for propositions; i.e., structured reasons justifying the belief in a proposition. Using defeasible rules, arguments need not be valid in all circumstances, therefore, it might be possible to construct an argument for a proposition as well as its negation. When arguments support conflicting propositions, one of the arguments must be defeated, which raises the question of \emph{which (sub-)arguments can be subject to defeat}? In legal argumentation, meta-rules determine the valid arguments by considering the last defeasible rule of each argument involved in a conflict. Since it is easier to evaluate arguments using their last rules, \emph{can a conflict be resolved by considering only the last defeasible rules of the arguments involved}? We propose a new argument system where, instead of deriving a defeat relation between arguments, \emph{undercutting-arguments} for the defeat of defeasible rules are constructed. This system allows us, (\textit{i}) to resolve conflicts (a generalization of rebutting arguments) using only the last rules of the arguments for inconsistencies, (\textit{ii}) to determine a set of valid (undefeated) arguments in linear time using an algorithm based on a JTMS, (\textit{iii}) to establish a relation with Default Logic, and (\textit{iv}) to prove closure properties such as \emph{cumulativity}. We also propose an extension of the argument system that enables \emph{reasoning by cases}.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑