多模式预测结果的稳健情景解释
Robust Scenario Interpretation from Multi-model Prediction Efforts
摘要:
传染病建模和气候建模中的多模型预测工作涉及多个团队独立地在各种情景下进行预测。通常,这些情景是由未来决策的存在和不存在产生的,例如,没有疫苗接种(情景A)与疫苗接种(情景B)。这些模型为每一种情景提供了概率预测。获得关于决策影响的置信区间(例如,避免的死亡人数)对决策很重要。然而,仅从各个场景的概率预测中获得紧边界是困难的,因为联合概率是未知的。此外,由于包括重写模拟的需要以及存储和传输要求的各种原因,模型可能不能生成联合概率分布。在不要求提交模型进行额外工作的情况下,我们的目标是估计由于决策变量而导致的结果的非平凡界限。我们首先证明,在一个关键的假设下,一个$α-$置信区间上的情况下的预测的差异,可以得到的预测的分位数。然后,我们展示了如何在放松该假设后估计置信区间。我们使用我们的方法来估计置信区间的减少病例,死亡,并根据模型提交给美国情景建模中心由于疫苗接种住院。
英文摘要:
Multi-model prediction efforts in infectious disease modeling and climate modeling involve multiple teams independently producing projections under various scenarios. Often these scenarios are produced by the presence and absence of a decision in the future, e.g., no vaccinations (scenario A) vs vaccinations (scenario B) available in the future. The models submit probabilistic projections for each of the scenarios. Obtaining a confidence interval on the impact of the decision (e.g., number of deaths averted) is important for decision making. However, obtaining tight bounds only from the probabilistic projections for the individual scenarios is difficult, as the joint probability is not known. Further, the models may not be able to generate the joint probability distribution due to various reasons including the need to rewrite simulations, and storage and transfer requirements. Without asking the submitting models for additional work, we aim to estimate a non-trivial bound on the outcomes due to the decision variable. We first prove, under a key assumption, that an $α-$confidence interval on the difference of scenario predictions can be obtained given only the quantiles of the predictions. Then we show how to estimate a confidence interval after relaxing that assumption. We use our approach to estimate confidence intervals on reduction in cases, deaths, and hospitalizations due to vaccinations based on model submissions to the US Scenario Modeling Hub.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。