看到你所相信的,还是相信你所看到的?置信偏差相关估计
Seeing What You Believe or Believing What You See? Belief Biases Correlation Estimation
摘要:
当一个分析师或科学家对世界是如何运作的有一个信念时,他们的思维可能会偏向于这个信念。因此,科学的一个基本原则是通过测试一个人对客观数据的信念的预测来最大限度地减少这种偏见。但解释可视化数据是一个复杂的感知和认知过程。通过两个众包实验,我们证明,所谓的客观评估的相关关系的强度可以影响观众如何强烈相信这种关系的存在。参与者查看了描述有意义的变量对之间关系的散点图(例如,环境法规和空气质量的数量),并估计其相关性。他们还估计了用通用的“X”和“Y”轴标记的相同散点图的相关性。在一个单独的部分中,他们还报告了他们认为有意义的变量对之间存在相关性的强烈程度。与标记有意义的变量对的散点图相比,参与者在查看标记有通用轴的散点图时更准确地估计相关性。此外,当观众认为两个变量应该有很强的关系时,他们高估了这些变量之间的相关性,r值约为0.1。当他们认为变量应该是不相关的,他们低估了相关性的r值约为0.1。虽然数据可视化通常被认为是向观众呈现客观事实,但这些结果表明,现有的个人信念甚至会使人们从数据中提取的客观统计值产生偏差。
英文摘要:
When an analyst or scientist has a belief about how the world works, their thinking can be biased in favor of that belief. Therefore, one bedrock principle of science is to minimize that bias by testing the predictions of one's belief against objective data. But interpreting visualized data is a complex perceptual and cognitive process. Through two crowdsourced experiments, we demonstrate that supposedly objective assessments of the strength of a correlational relationship can be influenced by how strongly a viewer believes in the existence of that relationship. Participants viewed scatterplots depicting a relationship between meaningful variable pairs (e.g., number of environmental regulations and air quality) and estimated their correlations. They also estimated the correlation of the same scatterplots labeled instead with generic 'X' and 'Y' axes. In a separate section, they also reported how strongly they believed there to be a correlation between the meaningful variable pairs. Participants estimated correlations more accurately when they viewed scatterplots labeled with generic axes compared to scatterplots labeled with meaningful variable pairs. Furthermore, when viewers believed that two variables should have a strong relationship, they overestimated correlations between those variables by an r-value of about 0.1. When they believed that the variables should be unrelated, they underestimated the correlations by an r-value of about 0.1. While data visualizations are typically thought to present objective truths to the viewer, these results suggest that existing personal beliefs can bias even objective statistical values people extract from data.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。