arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2206.04767cs.HC
收藏

当我们说“洞察”时,我们究竟在指什么?现有理论的形式化综合

What Do We Mean When We Say "Insight"? A Formal Synthesis of Existing Theory

Leilani Battle, Alvitta Ottley

AI总结:

本文针对可视化系统中洞察定义不一致导致理论模型难以应用的问题,综合文献中的一致结构提出统一的洞察形式化表达,并通过理论案例研究对比现有理论,揭示了推理用户领域知识及利用数据挖掘协同方法的研究挑战。

摘要:

研究人员已经推导出许多理论模型,用于在用户与可视化系统交互时规范其洞察。这些表示对于理解洞察发现过程至关重要,例如在推断导致洞察的用户交互模式或评估所报告洞察的严密性时。然而,理论模型往往难以应用于现有工具和用户研究,这通常是由于洞察及其组成部分的定义方式存在差异。本文引起人们对可视化文献中反复出现的一致结构的关注,并描述了这些结构如何连接多种关于洞察的理论表示。我们利用这些结构综合出一种统一的洞察形式化表达,使更广泛的研究人员和开发者能够采用相应的模型。通过一系列理论案例研究,我们使用我们的形式化方法对现有理论进行了比较和对比,揭示了在推理用户领域知识以及利用数据挖掘和数据管理研究中的协同方法方面有趣的研究挑战。

英文摘要:

Researchers have derived many theoretical models for specifying users' insights as they interact with a visualization system. These representations are essential for understanding the insight discovery process, such as when inferring user interaction patterns that lead to insight or assessing the rigor of reported insights. However, theoretical models can be difficult to apply to existing tools and user studies, often due to discrepancies in how insight and its constituent parts are defined. This paper calls attention to the consistent structures that recur across the visualization literature and describes how they connect multiple theoretical representations of insight. We synthesize a unified formalism for insights using these structures, enabling a wider audience of researchers and developers to adopt the corresponding models. Through a series of theoretical case studies, we use our formalism to compare and contrast existing theories, revealing interesting research challenges in reasoning about a user's domain knowledge and leveraging synergistic approaches in data mining and data management research.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑