arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2206.03077cs.HCcs.CY
收藏

在线编码练习中反馈类型的探索性分析

An Exploratory Analysis of Feedback Types Used in Online Coding Exercises

Natalie Kiesler

摘要:

在线编码环境可以帮助支持计算学生以自己的速度获得编程实践。在这种自我指导的独立学习阶段,信息反馈尤其有益。本研究旨在识别CodingBat,Scratch和Blockly应用的反馈类型。由Susanne Narciss创造的辅导反馈以及Keuning,Jeuring和Heeren的子类型规范构成了理论基础。因此,五类详细的反馈(关于任务要求的知识,关于概念的知识,关于错误的知识,关于如何进行的知识,以及关于元认知的知识)及其子类型被用于分析可用的反馈选项。这项研究揭示了在确定反馈类型之间的明确界限方面的困难,因为所提供的反馈通常集成了一种以上的类型或子类型。此外,目前定义的反馈类型没有严格区分个性化和通用反馈。缺乏粒度也是显而易见的,在没有与任务的知识类型相关的子类型。因此,该分析对未来应用教学反馈的设计和调查具有一定的启示意义。它鼓励未来的研究反馈类型和他们的实现在编程练习的背景下,定义反馈类型,符合新手程序员的需求。

英文摘要:

Online coding environments can help support computing students gain programming practice at their own pace. Especially informative feedback can be beneficial during such self-guided, independent study phases. This research aims at the identification of feedback types applied by CodingBat, Scratch and Blockly. Tutoring feedback as coined by Susanne Narciss along with the specification of subtypes by Keuning, Jeuring and Heeren constitute the theoretical basis. Accordingly, the five categories of elaborated feedback (knowledge about task requirements, knowledge about concepts, knowledge about mistakes, knowledge about how to proceed, and knowledge about meta-cognition) and their subtypes were utilized for the analysis of available feedback options. The study revealed difficulties in identifying clear-cut boundaries between feedback types, as the offered feedback usually integrates more than one type or subtype. Moreover, currently defined feedback types do not rigorously distinguish individualized and generic feedback. The lack of granularity is also evident in the absence of subtypes relating to the knowledge type of the task. The analysis thus has implications for the future design and investigation of applied tutoring feedback. It encourages future research on feedback types and their implementation in the context of programming exercises to define feedback types that match the demands of novice programmers.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑