arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2205.08922cs.CY
收藏

我们玩的游戏:临界复杂性改善机器学习

The games we play: critical complexity improves machine learning

Abeba Birhane, David J. T. Sumpter

摘要:

当应用数学建模来捕获复杂系统时,通常会创建多个模型来表征该系统的不同方面。通常,一个层次的模型会产生一个在另一个层次上矛盾的预测,但两个模型都被接受,因为它们都是有用的。建模者的目标不是建立一个复杂系统的单一统一模型,而是承认捕获感兴趣系统的方法是无限的,同时提供自己的特定见解。我们将这种实用的复杂系统应用方法称为开放式机器学习(Open ML),它承认复杂系统是不可压缩的、动态的、非线性的、历史的、上下文的和充满价值的。在本文中,我们定义了开放ML,并将其与两种形式的ML的一些宏大叙事进行了对比:1)封闭ML,强调以最少的人类输入进行学习(例如Google的AlphaZero)和2)部分开放ML,用于参数化现有模型的ML。为了实现这一目标,我们使用关键复杂性理论来评估这些宏大的叙事,并将其与开放ML方法进行对比。具体来说,我们通过识别ML社区中玩的13个“游戏”来解构大ML“理论”。这些游戏为模型提供了虚假的合法性,助长了对人工智能能力的过度承诺和炒作,减少了对该主题的更广泛参与,导致加剧不平等和造成歧视的模型,并最终扼杀了研究中的创造力。我们认为,ML的最佳实践应该更符合批判的复杂性观点,而不是理性主义的宏大叙事。

英文摘要:

When mathematical modelling is applied to capture a complex system, multiple models are often created that characterize different aspects of that system. Often, a model at one level will produce a prediction which is contradictory at another level but both models are accepted because they are both useful. Rather than aiming to build a single unified model of a complex system, the modeller acknowledges the infinity of ways of capturing the system of interest, while offering their own specific insight. We refer to this pragmatic applied approach to complex systems -- one which acknowledges that they are incompressible, dynamic, nonlinear, historical, contextual, and value-laden -- as Open Machine Learning (Open ML). In this paper we define Open ML and contrast it with some of the grand narratives of ML of two forms: 1) Closed ML, ML which emphasizes learning with minimal human input (e.g. Google's AlphaZero) and 2) Partially Open ML, ML which is used to parameterize existing models. To achieve this, we use theories of critical complexity to both evaluate these grand narratives and contrast them with the Open ML approach. Specifically, we deconstruct grand ML `theories' by identifying thirteen 'games' played in the ML community. These games lend false legitimacy to models, contribute to over-promise and hype about the capabilities of artificial intelligence, reduce wider participation in the subject, lead to models that exacerbate inequality and cause discrimination and ultimately stifle creativity in research. We argue that best practice in ML should be more consistent with critical complexity perspectives than with rationalist, grand narratives.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑