说书人:报纸上同时引用了睡美人和王子在醒来之前的话
Storyteller: The papers co-citing Sleeping Beauty and Prince before awakening
摘要:
在累积优势(CA)模型中,这是理解引用动态机制的最基本方法之一,论文的引用取决于它们被引用的次数。另一方面,CA中没有包括的一个实质性影响是,一些令人惊讶的发现在出版很长一段时间后突然获得引用。这种现象被称为睡美人(SB)。由于颠覆性的发现需要研究界进行长时间的讨论才能接受,因此SB可以捕捉创新性的发现,并揭示颠覆性科学知识生产的本质。文献计量学家们在研究学术期刊的引文爆发机制时,认为每一个学术期刊都存在一个“王子”(PR),它可以成为学术期刊觉醒的触发器。例如,获得诺贝尔化学奖的绿色荧光蛋白(GFP)的发现被忽视了30年,直到同样获得诺贝尔化学奖的Chalfie和Tsien开发出一种方法,将GFP用作基因工程中的标记蛋白。然而,Chalfies和Tsiens的研究如何重新揭示研究界隐藏的知识?如果能够厘清这种从无到有的再发现机制,将有助于科学支持和政策决策。本研究提出了一个故事讲述者,侧重于SB和PR之间的连接之前,SB获得引文共引爆发。回顾过去,PR被认为是唤醒SB的论文,但在PR提交时,它并不容易被检测为SB觉醒的触发器。我们将SB和PR在SB引用爆发前共同引用的论文命名为Storyteller(ST),并分析(1)ST如何有助于拓宽SB和PR联系的新颖性和(2)ST在觉醒后的引用爆发中的领先程度。
英文摘要:
In the Cumulative Advantage(CA) model, which is one of the most fundamental approaches to understand the mechanism of citation dynamics, papers receive citations depending on how much they have been already cited. On the other hand, a substantial effect not included in CA is that some surprising discoveries suddenly acquire citations after a long time from publishing. This phenomenon is known as Sleeping Beauty(SB). Since disrupting discoveries need long-time discussion by the research community to accept, SBs can capture innovative findings and reveal the nature of disruptive scientific knowledge production. To research SBs citation burst mechanism, bibliometricians consider the existence of the Prince(PR) for each SBs, which can be the trigger of SBs awakeness. For example, the discovery of Green Fluorescent Protein(GFP), which got Nobel prize in chemistry, had been overlooked for 30 years until Chalfie and Tsien, who also received the prize, developed a method to use GFP as a marker protein in genetic engineering. However, how does Chalfies and Tsiens research relight the hidden knowledge in the research community? If we can clarify such a mechanism rediscovering from nearly nothing, it can be helpful in science support and policy decision-making. This study proposes a Storyteller that focuses on the connection between SB and PR before SB gets citation burst by co-citation. PR is found to be the paper awakening SB in retrospect, but it is not easy to detect it as the trigger of SBs awakeness at the time of PR submission. We named the papers which co-cites SB and PR before the citation burst of SB as Storyteller(ST) and analyze (1) how ST contributes to broadening the novelty of SB&PR connections and (2) how much ST leads the citation burst after awakening.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。