arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2203.08227cs.CYcs.LG
收藏

性别问题:将性别/性别纳入医学机器学习的常见陷阱以及如何避免它们

Sex Trouble: Common pitfalls in incorporating sex/gender in medical machine learning and how to avoid them

Harvard Law School(哈佛法学院);Swarthmore College(斯沃斯莫尔学院)

Kendra Albert, Maggie Delano

摘要:

关于性和性别的错误假设深深植根于医疗系统中,包括它们是二元的,静态的和一致的。机器学习研究人员必须了解这些假设的性质,以避免使它们永久化。在这篇观点文章中,我们确定了研究人员在处理性别/性别数据时经常犯的三个错误:“性别混淆”,未能识别数据集中的性别是什么意思或不意味着什么;“性别痴迷”,认为性别,特别是出生时分配的性别,是大多数应用程序的相关变量;以及“性/性别滑动”,即性和性别的混淆,即使在只知道其中一个或另一个的情况下。然后,我们将讨论这些陷阱如何出现在基于电子健康记录数据的机器学习研究中,这些数据通常用于从回顾性分析患者结果到开发预测风险和管理护理的算法。最后,我们提供了一系列关于机器学习研究人员如何进行研究和算法的建议,这些研究和算法可以更仔细地处理性/性别问题,更好地服务于所有患者,包括变性人。

英文摘要:

False assumptions about sex and gender are deeply embedded in the medical system, including that they are binary, static, and concordant. Machine learning researchers must understand the nature of these assumptions in order to avoid perpetuating them. In this perspectives piece, we identify three common mistakes that researchers make when dealing with sex/gender data: "sex confusion", the failure to identity what sex in a dataset does or doesn't mean; "sex obsession", the belief that sex, specifically sex assigned at birth, is the relevant variable for most applications; and "sex/gender slippage", the conflation of sex and gender even in contexts where only one or the other is known. We then discuss how these pitfalls show up in machine learning studies based on electronic health record data, which is commonly used for everything from retrospective analysis of patient outcomes to the development of algorithms to predict risk and administer care. Finally, we offer a series of recommendations about how machine learning researchers can produce both research and algorithms that more carefully engage with questions of sex/gender, better serving all patients, including transgender people.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑