arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2203.02626physics.ed-ph
收藏

百分比等级放大了入门物理学中的种族/民族不平等

Percent Grade Scale Amplifies Racial/Ethnic Inequities in Introductory Physics

Cassandra A. Paul, David J. Webb

摘要:

在以前的工作中,我们分析了95个班级的数据库,表明百分等级量表与比4.0等级量表高得多的学生不及格率相关。本文建立在这项工作的基础上,调查两种规模下发生的公平差距。通过采用“课程赤字模型”,我们将缩小差距的责任归于那些负责指导课程的政策的人。当比较课程成绩在使用百分量表分级的课程与那些在使用4.0量表分级的课程,我们发现,学生识别为属于种族或少数民族在物理学中代表性不足遭受等级处罚下两个等级尺度,但遭受额外的处罚下百分量表分级课程。然后,我们使用的分数A级每个学生获得的个别考试项目作为代理的教师的看法,每个学生的理解的课程材料,以控制学生的理解,并发现,额外的年级处罚学生从组中代表性不足的物理学生遭受的百分比尺度评分是独立的学生的理解物理。当我们控制更多的学生水平的变量,以确定源的等级尺度依赖的惩罚,我们发现,它主要是低F级(部分学分)考试的问题,这些不平等的来源。我们提出了一个论点,从百分制分级切换到4.0级(或类似的等级)可以减少20- 25%的公平差距,而无需进行任何其他课程的变化或控制学生之间的任何传入的差异。

英文摘要:

In previous work we analyzed databases for 95 classes to show that the percent grade scale was correlated with a much higher student fail rate than the 4.0 grade scale. This paper builds on this work and investigates equity gaps occurring under both scales. By employing a "Course Deficit Model" we attribute the responsibility for closing the gaps to those who are responsible for the policies that guide the course. When comparing course grades in classes graded using the percent scale with those in courses graded using the 4.0 scale, we find that students identifying as belonging to racial or ethnic minorities underrepresented in physics suffer a grade penalty under both grade scales but suffer an extra penalty under percent scale graded courses. We then use the fraction of A grades each student earns on individual exam items as a proxy for the instructor's perception of each student's understanding of the course material to control for student understanding and find that the extra grade penalty students from groups underrepresented in physics students suffer under percent scale grading is independent of the student's understanding of physics. When we control for more student level variables to determine the source of the grade scale dependent penalty, we find that it is primarily the low F grades (partial credit scores) on exam problems that are the source of these inequities. We present an argument that switching from percent scale grading to a 4.0 grade scale (or similar grades scale) could reduce equity gaps by 20-25\% without making any other course changes or controlling for any incoming differences between students.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑