arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2202.07349cs.HC
收藏

IF-City:可理解的公平城市规划,以衡量,解释和减轻不平等

IF-City: Intelligible Fair City Planning to Measure, Explain and Mitigate Inequality

Yan Lyu, Hangxin Lu, Min Kyung Lee, Gerhard Schmitt, Brian Y. Lim

摘要:

随着人工智能(AI)的日益普及,人们提出了许多可视化分析工具来检查公平性,但它们主要集中在数据科学家用户身上。相反,解决公平性问题必须具有包容性,并让领域专家使用专门的工具和工作流程。因此,特定领域的可视化需要算法公平性。此外,虽然人工智能公平性方面的许多工作都集中在预测性决策上,但在公平分配和规划方面所做的工作却很少,这需要人类的专业知识和迭代设计来整合无数的约束。我们提出了可理解的公平分配(IF-Alloc)框架,该框架利用因果归因(为什么),对比(为什么不)和反事实推理(如果,如何)的解释来帮助领域专家评估和减轻分配问题中的不公平。我们将该框架应用于公平的城市规划,以设计为不同居民类型提供平等享受设施和福利的城市。具体来说,我们提出了一个交互式的可视化工具,可理解的公平城市规划师(IF-City),以帮助城市规划师感知群体之间的不平等,识别和属性的不平等的来源,并减轻不平等与自动分配模拟和满足约束的建议。我们展示和评估的使用和实用性的IF-City在纽约市,美国的一个真实的社区,与来自多个国家的执业城市规划师,并讨论推广我们的研究结果,应用程序和框架,以其他用例和公平分配的应用。

英文摘要:

With the increasing pervasiveness of Artificial Intelligence (AI), many visual analytics tools have been proposed to examine fairness, but they mostly focus on data scientist users. Instead, tackling fairness must be inclusive and involve domain experts with specialized tools and workflows. Thus, domain-specific visualizations are needed for algorithmic fairness. Furthermore, while much work on AI fairness has focused on predictive decisions, less has been done for fair allocation and planning, which require human expertise and iterative design to integrate myriad constraints. We propose the Intelligible Fair Allocation (IF-Alloc) Framework that leverages explanations of causal attribution (Why), contrastive (Why Not) and counterfactual reasoning (What If, How To) to aid domain experts to assess and alleviate unfairness in allocation problems. We apply the framework to fair urban planning for designing cities that provide equal access to amenities and benefits for diverse resident types. Specifically, we propose an interactive visual tool, Intelligible Fair City Planner (IF-City), to help urban planners to perceive inequality across groups, identify and attribute sources of inequality, and mitigate inequality with automatic allocation simulations and constraint-satisfying recommendations. We demonstrate and evaluate the usage and usefulness of IF-City on a real neighborhood in New York City, US, with practicing urban planners from multiple countries, and discuss generalizing our findings, application, and framework to other use cases and applications of fair allocation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑