arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2202.05548cs.HC
收藏

预发布审核的风险、收益与后果:来自17个维基百科语言版本的证据

The Risks, Benefits, and Consequences of Prepublication Moderation: Evidence from 17 Wikipedia Language Editions

Chau Tran, Kaylea Champion, Benjamin Mako Hill, Rachel Greenstadt

AI总结:

本文通过分析17个维基百科语言版本部署的预发布审核系统FlaggedRevs的面板数据,发现该系统有效阻止低质量贡献可见,但对贡献量和质量影响温和,表明对其主要负面影响的担忧被夸大。

摘要:

许多在线社区依赖发布后审核机制,即允许贡献者(即使是被视为有风险的贡献者)立即发布内容,审核在事后进行。另一种机制是在发布前审核内容。一些社区反对预发布审核,认为它会降低新成员的贡献乐趣,并让资深社区成员因额外审核工作而分心。我们对名为FlaggedRevs的预发布审核系统的效果进行了实证分析,该系统已被多个维基百科语言版本部署。我们使用来自17个大型维基百科版本的面板数据,测试了一系列关于该系统对活动水平和贡献质量影响的假设。我们发现,该系统在阻止低质量贡献可见方面非常有效。尽管有证据表明该系统抑制了无账户用户的参与,但我们的分析表明,该系统对贡献量和质量的影响至多是温和的。我们的研究结果表明,对预发布审核系统对贡献质量和项目生产力的主要负面影响的担忧可能被夸大了。

英文摘要:

Many online communities rely on postpublication moderation where contributors, even those that are perceived as being risky, are allowed to publish material immediately and where moderation takes place after the fact. An alternative arrangement involves moderating content before publication. A range of communities have argued against prepublication moderation by suggesting that it makes contributing less enjoyable for new members and that it will distract established community members with extra moderation work. We present an empirical analysis of the effects of a prepublication moderation system called FlaggedRevs that was deployed by several Wikipedia language editions. We used panel data from 17 large Wikipedia editions to test a series of hypotheses related to the effect of the system on activity levels and contribution quality. We found that the system was very effective at keeping low-quality contributions from ever becoming visible. Although there is some evidence that the system discouraged participation among users without accounts, our analysis suggests that the system's effects on contribution volume and quality were moderate at most. Our findings imply that concerns regarding the major negative effects of prepublication moderation systems on contribution quality and project productivity may be overstated.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑