大鱼和小池塘:为什么部门h指数不应该用于大学排名
Big fish and small ponds: why the departmental h-index should not be used to rank universities
摘要:
本文重新考虑了所谓的组或部门h指数的大小依赖性。虽然单位规模对这种集体措施的影响在十年前就已经得到了证明,但仍然可以找到基于这一指标的机构评级,并且仍然影响着许多研究机构的声誉和资金。本文的目的是以一种简单的方式来证明这种集体研究质量评估方法的谬误,重点是h指数的原始形式。我们发现,随机重新洗牌真正的scientometric数据(不同数量的引用)之间的机构规模不同,同时保持其研究成果的数量,对他们的部门的h指数几乎没有影响。这表明,基于集体h指数的评级的相对位置不仅取决于特定研究成果的质量(影响),还取决于它们的数量。因此,作为研究团体、机构或期刊等总体水平比较的基础,以其原始形式应用集体h指数是有争议的。我们提出了一个可能的补救措施,这是可实施的方式,是简单和易于理解的h指数本身。
英文摘要:
The size-dependent nature of the so-called group or departmental h-index is reconsidered in this paper. While the influence of unit size on such collective measures was already demonstrated a decade ago, institutional ratings based on this metric can still be found and still impact on the reputations and funding of many research institutions. The aim of this paper is to demonstrate the fallacy of this approach to collective research-quality assessment in a simple way, focusing on the h-index in its original form. We show that randomly reshuffling real scientometric data (varying numbers of citations) amongst institutions of varying size, while maintaining the volume of their research outputs, has little effect on their departmental h-index. This suggests that the relative position in ratings based on the collective h-index is determined not only by quality (impact) of particular research outputs but by their volume. Therefore, the application of the collective h-index in its original form is disputable as a basement for comparison at aggregated levels such as to research groups, institutions or journals. We suggest a possible remedy for this failing which is implementable in a manner that is as simple and understandable as the h-index itself.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。