别让Ricci v. DeStefano案束缚住你:针对招聘悖论的偏见感知型法律解决方案
Don't let Ricci v. DeStefano Hold You Back: A Bias-Aware Legal Solution to the Hiring Paradox
AI总结:
针对企业解决就业不平等时面临的招聘悖论,本研究结合Ricci v. DeStefano案法律细节与分级法律实践,提出基于偏序集的偏见感知技术,既符合Title VII要求,又能缓解就业流程固有偏见。
摘要:
试图解决就业不平等问题的企业正面临招聘悖论。若未能解决劳动力队伍失衡问题,企业可能会面临法律制裁与审查,但主动采取措施解决这些问题同样可能引发法律纠纷。近期微软(Microsoft)和富国银行(Wells Fargo)与劳工部联邦合同合规计划办公室(OFCCP)的冲突并非个例,且这类情况很可能会持续存在。更令人困惑的是,现有关于Ricci v. DeStefano案的学术研究往往认为这一悖论无解。4/5规则这类规避性做法进一步凸显了行动不足与行动过度之间的矛盾。\n在本研究中,我们提出了一种可同时应对法律与算法层面挑战的有效方法,以破解这一招聘悖论。我们剖析了Ricci v. DeStefano案的细节,并通过引入用于评估候选人的“分级(banding)”法律实践,拓展了认为特定算法化就业手段具备合法性的法律研究方向。我们由此证明,偏见感知技术可用于诊断并缓解就业流程中的“固有”不利因素。我们运用偏序集(partially ordered sets)的理论工具来处理评估数据中的不确定性。该方法让我们得以摆脱“将人等同于数字”的评估模式,转而将人作为独立个体看待——这正是《民权法案》第七章(Title VII)在就业领域所追求的特性。
英文摘要:
Companies that try to address inequality in employment face a hiring paradox. Failing to address workforce imbalance can result in legal sanctions and scrutiny, but proactive measures to address these issues might result in the same legal conflict. Recent run-ins of Microsoft and Wells Fargo with the Labor Department's Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) are not isolated and are likely to persist. To add to the confusion, existing scholarship on Ricci v. DeStefano often deems solutions to this paradox impossible. Circumventive practices such as the 4/5ths rule further illustrate tensions between too little action and too much action. In this work, we give a powerful way to solve this hiring paradox that tracks both legal and algorithmic challenges. We unpack the nuances of Ricci v. DeStefano and extend the legal literature arguing that certain algorithmic approaches to employment are allowed by introducing the legal practice of banding to evaluate candidates. We thus show that a bias-aware technique can be used to diagnose and mitigate "built-in" headwinds in the employment pipeline. We use the machinery of partially ordered sets to handle the presence of uncertainty in evaluations data. This approach allows us to move away from treating "people as numbers" to treating people as individuals -- a property that is sought after by Title VII in the context of employment.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。