腕关节背侧和桡侧四角融合术两种手术结构的力学性能比较
Mechanical performance comparison of two surgical constructs for wrist four-corner arthrodesis via dorsal and radial approaches
摘要:
背景资料:四角关节融合术,包括融合四个腕骨,同时去除舟状骨,是治疗晚期腕关节炎的标准手术。如今,它可以通过将钢板固定到骨上使用背侧入路进行,并且正在开发一种新的桡侧入路。到目前为止,对于四角关节融合术的生物力学最佳和最可靠的手术结构还没有达成共识。研究方法:为了对其进行生物力学评价,从而帮助外科医生选择最佳植入物方向(径向或背侧),在代表腕部所有主要结构的3D有限元模型上虚拟模拟了两种不同的四角关节固定术手术结构。两个不同的现实负载集被应用到模型中,代表老年人的常见任务。结果:结果的一致性进行了评估,通过与文献的腕骨上计算的力的大小进行比较。计算了桡骨和背侧接骨板的Von Mises应力分布。应力集中位于两种手术结构的接骨板-螺钉界面,背侧接骨板的最大应力值为413 MPa,而桡骨接骨板为326 MPa,这意味着背侧入路的应力水平更不利。解释:尽管在一种载荷情况下发现了一些弯曲应力,但在另一种载荷情况下,桡骨接骨板的机械性能更稳健。尽管存在一些局限性,但本研究首次提供了量化证据,证明新开发的桡侧手术结构在机械上与背侧手术结构一样有效。
英文摘要:
Background: Four-corner arthrodesis, which involves fusing four carpal bones while removing the scaphoid bone, is a standard surgery for the treatment of advanced stages of wrist arthritis. Nowadays, it can be performed using a dorsal approach by fixing a plate to the bones and a new radial approach is in development. To date, there is no consensus on the biomechanically optimal and most reliable surgical construct for four-corner arthrodesis. Methods: To evaluate them biomechanically and thus assist the surgeon in choosing the best implant orientation, radial or dorsal, the two different four-corner arthrodesis surgical constructs were virtually simulated on a 3D finite element model representing all major structures of the wrist. Two different realistic load sets were applied to the model, representing common tasks for the elderly. Findings: Results consistency was assessed by comparing with the literature the force magnitude computed on the carpal bones. The Von Mises stress distribution in the radial and dorsal plates were calculated. Stress concentration was located at the plate-screw interface for both surgical constructs, with a maximum stress value of 413 MPa for the dorsal plate compared to 326 MPa for the radial plate, meaning that the stress levels are more unfavourable in the dorsal approach. Interpretation: Although some bending stress was found in one load case, the radial plate was mechanically more robust in the other load case. Despite some limitations, this study provides, for the first time, quantified evidence that the newly developed radial surgical construct is mechanically as efficient as the dorsal surgical construct.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。