超大规模系统中的系统和软件架构协调实践
System and Software architecting harmonization practices in ultra-large-scale Systems of Systems
摘要:
背景:系统的体系架构(SoS)所带来的挑战激发了该领域大量的研究工作。然而,文献是缺乏的,当涉及到的学科之间的相互作用,在架构过程中,在解决这些challenges.Objective的一个关键因素:本文的目的是有助于这条线的研究,通过确认和扩展以前的特点,从系统和软件工程,在超大规模的SoS采用的架构协调的做法。方法:我们对平方公里阵列(SKA)项目进行了验证性案例研究,以评估和扩展我们对LOFAR/LOFAR2.0射电望远镜项目的探索性案例的研究结果。在此过程中,进行了一项预研究,以映射先前研究的结果与SKA背景。然后设计了一个调查,通过收集和分析的46 SKA工程师的意见。结果如下:该研究在不同程度上证实了探索性案例中确定的四种实践,并提供了关于它们的进一步见解,即:(1)长期系统需求引起的学科之间的摩擦,以及如何通过中期和短期需求来改善它们;(2)对多个敏捷团队具有横向影响的设计选择对系统架构产生间接影响的方式;(3)这些设计选择通常是如何由指导早期系统分解的标准引起的;(4)缺乏有关接口动态元素的细节的似乎经常出现的问题;(5)使用机器可读的接口规范来调整硬件/软件开发过程。
英文摘要:
Context: The challenges posed by the architecting of System of Systems (SoS) has motivated a significant number of research efforts in the area. However, literature is lacking when it comes to the interplay between the disciplines involved in the architecting process, a key factor in addressing these challenges.Objective: This paper aims to contribute to this line of research by confirming and extending previously characterized architecting harmonization practices from Systems and Software Engineering, adopted in an ultra-large-scale SoS. Method: We conducted a confirmatory case study on the Square-Kilometre Array (SKA) project to evaluate and extend the findings of our exploratory case on the LOFAR/LOFAR2.0 radio-telescope projects. In doing so, a pre-study was conducted to map the findings of the previous study with respect to the SKA context. A survey was then designed, through which the views of 46 SKA engineers were collected and analyzed. Results: The study confirmed in various degrees the four practices identified in the exploratory case, and provided further insights about them, namely: (1) the friction between disciplines caused by long-term system requirements, and how they can be ameliorated through intermediate, short-term requirements; (2) the way design choices with a cross-cutting impact on multiple agile teams have an indirect impact on the system architecture; (3) how these design choices are often caused by the criteria that guided early system decomposition; (4) the seemingly recurrent issue with the lack of details about the dynamic elements of the interfaces; and (5) the use of machine-readable interface specifications for aligning hardware/software development processes.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。