从真值开始:从实践到原则做AI伦理
From the Ground Truth Up: Doing AI Ethics from Practice to Principles
摘要:
最近的人工智能伦理学专注于将抽象的原则向下应用于实践。这篇论文的方向正好相反。伦理见解是从人工智能设计师处理有形人类问题的生活经验中产生的,然后向上循环,影响围绕这些问题的理论辩论:1)应该通过可解释性或准确的性能来寻求人工智能的可靠性吗?2)人工智能到底应该被认为是值得信赖的,还是可靠性是一个更可取的目标?3)人工智能伦理应该以保护用户为导向,还是以促进创新为导向?具体的答案不如更大的证据那么重要,即人工智能伦理目前对理论原则不平衡,并且将受益于更多地接触接地实践和困境。
英文摘要:
Recent AI ethics has focused on applying abstract principles downward to practice. This paper moves in the other direction. Ethical insights are generated from the lived experiences of AI-designers working on tangible human problems, and then cycled upward to influence theoretical debates surrounding these questions: 1) Should AI as trustworthy be sought through explainability, or accurate performance? 2) Should AI be considered trustworthy at all, or is reliability a preferable aim? 3) Should AI ethics be oriented toward establishing protections for users, or toward catalyzing innovation? Specific answers are less significant than the larger demonstration that AI ethics is currently unbalanced toward theoretical principles, and will benefit from increased exposure to grounded practices and dilemmas.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。