在谷歌搜索中,参与度超过了对党派和不可靠新闻的曝光
Engagement Outweighs Exposure to Partisan and Unreliable News within Google Search
摘要:
如果流行的在线平台系统地让用户接触党派和不可靠的新闻,它们可能会导致政治两极分化加剧等社会问题。这种担忧是回音室和过滤气泡辩论的核心,它们批评了用户选择和算法策展在引导用户到不同的在线信息源中所扮演的角色。这些角色可以通过曝光度(使用在线平台时看到的URL)和参与度(在该平台上或更普遍地浏览网页时选择的URL)来衡量。然而,由于获得生态有效的暴露数据的挑战-真实用户在常规平台使用期间所看到的-这方面的研究通常只检查参与数据,或通过模拟行为或推断来估计暴露。尽管它们在当代信息生态系统中处于中心地位,但很少有这样的研究关注网络搜索,更少有人研究任何平台上的曝光率和参与度。为了解决这些差距,我们进行了一项两波研究,将调查与2018年和2020年美国大选期间谷歌搜索的曝光和参与度的生态有效措施相结合。我们发现,参与者的党派认同与他们在谷歌搜索上接触到的党派和不可靠新闻的数量有一个小而不一致的关系,与他们选择遵循的搜索结果有一个更一致的关系,与他们的整体参与度有最一致的关系。也就是说,与我们的参与者在谷歌搜索上接触到的新闻来源相比,我们在他们的参与选择中发现了更多的身份一致和不可靠的新闻来源,无论是在谷歌搜索中还是整体上。这些结果表明,在谷歌搜索上曝光和参与党派或不可靠的新闻主要不是由算法策展驱动的,而是由用户自己的选择驱动的。
英文摘要:
If popular online platforms systematically expose their users to partisan and unreliable news, they could potentially contribute to societal issues like rising political polarization. This concern is central to the echo chamber and filter bubble debates, which critique the roles that user choice and algorithmic curation play in guiding users to different online information sources. These roles can be measured in terms of exposure, the URLs seen while using an online platform, and engagement, the URLs selected while on that platform or browsing the web more generally. However, due to the challenges of obtaining ecologically valid exposure data--what real users saw during their regular platform use--studies in this vein often only examine engagement data, or estimate exposure via simulated behavior or inference. Despite their centrality to the contemporary information ecosystem, few such studies have focused on web search, and even fewer have examined both exposure and engagement on any platform. To address these gaps, we conducted a two-wave study pairing surveys with ecologically valid measures of exposure and engagement on Google Search during the 2018 and 2020 US elections. We found that participants' partisan identification had a small and inconsistent relationship with the amount of partisan and unreliable news they were exposed to on Google Search, a more consistent relationship with the search results they chose to follow, and the most consistent relationship with their overall engagement. That is, compared to the news sources our participants were exposed to on Google Search, we found more identity-congruent and unreliable news sources in their engagement choices, both within Google Search and overall. These results suggest that exposure and engagement with partisan or unreliable news on Google Search are not primarily driven by algorithmic curation, but by users' own choices.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。